If Napa suspended, who comes in?

[Lydon]

Although I agree with Gus that the Napa hit and charge is a reaction to the social media outburst since it happened,Dylan should know better after the last time this happened.

As an experienced Origin campaigner he know the risks involved and unfortunately has hurt the team heading into the Finals!

[Thirteen]

Butcher for me over Napa anyway. One less bonehead to wreck our chances.

We're down to 3 now - Fergo Toops Friend.

If they stick to what they do best and minimise the errors then we'll be fine.

Butcher has the physical presence of a cockroach compared to Napa.

[Thirteen]

Isaac needs to start at prop and have either JWH or SST come off the bench to give us a little impact.

[Tommy Smith]

Butcher has the physical presence of a cockroach compared to Napa.

Unfortunately Napa has the mental aptitude of a cockroach it would seem.

But Liu to prop could work.

11. Cords
12. Matto
13. Radley
8. Jwh
9. Friend
10. Liu

14. SST
15. Tetevano
16. Butcher
17. Aubo

[Lydon]

Isaac needs to start at prop and have either JWH or SST come off the bench to give us a little impact.

I like the idea of Liu to prop,I am sure he has played there in the past..

[Thirteen]

I like the idea of Liu to prop,I am sure he has played there in the past..

He has. Liu can handle the defense and he runs hard up the middle.

[Novo rooster]

Don't know what everyone else thinks but our form seemed to be on the way up when Napa was injured. Collins at least provided some go forward and quicker play the balls. I could be wrong but Napa missing is not as bad as some think.

[Salvatori Grubber]

Imagine Napa in a gf. He’d go utterly mental - it’d be awesome.

[stsae]

Don't know what everyone else thinks but our form seemed to be on the way up when Napa was injured. Collins at least provided some go forward and quicker play the balls. I could be wrong but Napa missing is not as bad as some think.

He was voted the biggest hitter in the game by a long way for a reason. Opposition players don't like playing him.

Collins is raw. Potential yes but some of his basic misses in those games he played in this year shows he aint ready to tie Napas boots yet.

You are wrong IMO.

[Cockadoodledoo]

He has. Liu can handle the defense and he runs hard up the middle.

It would keep him out of the backline.

[morley101]

I would keep JWH in cotton wool till week 1 of the finals.... I would bring in Collins,

[Lydon]

I would keep JWH in cotton wool till week 1 of the finals.... I would bring in Collins,

I agree with this,as long as he isn’t short of match fitness for a finals match!

[Johnny Brass]

I would keep JWH in cotton wool till week 1 of the finals.... I would bring in Collins,

Agree with this, it's imperative Jwh is fully fit so I'd give him the extra week off

[Bigchook]

Collins for me. He's come a long way in the space of a year. Hopefully he keeps progressing. Time to give the young fella a crack at the big time.

[ism22]

personally I feel we should challenge any strong charge. Good solicitor will argue prescedence

should he be suspended, suggest your bench assuming jwh for napa
14. Matterson
15. Collins
16, maubs
17 the farmer

maubs versility over butcher. Too small for both. Thoughts?

I think...
8. JWH
9. Friend
10. SST
11. Cords
12. Liu
13 Radley

Subs: Butcher, Tetevano, Maubs, Matto

It's not actually a net loss when compadred with last week... JWH in, Napa our.