Our play makers getting belted

[Rooster_6]

Call it what you want, Sue's sight of the ball was impacted by Cronk turning his back to pass. He does it quite regularly and there's another example of it in the Storm game you put up to have a look at. JWH was standing there and watched Ponga kick the ball and still went on with the tackle. And you're calling me illogical?

He is side on to Sue when he passes. It's not what I want to call it, it's fact.

I don't know what JWH has to do with this, I said his shot was late.

[Headless Chook]

Will be interesting to see what Sue cops as a suspension.

I reckon JWH and the Roosters will be keeping a close eye on the suspension handed down

You brought up JWH right there as if the two tackles were similar and then highlighted the inconsistencies around the match review committee in another one. Sue's tackle got the penalty it deserved, I don't think it warranted a suspension, you think otherwise, fair enough.

[Mickie Lane]

I have no problem with play makers getting targeted. Its the trump position & the whole time I have watched or played footy its been that way.

[Darkone]

was a cheap shot on Ponga

JWH lost cred with that, I'm sure he'd agree as he's been above that the past years

[roosterproud]

Sue's tackle was a lot different to JWH and I have no issue with it not copping a suspension. Unlike Ponga, Cronk had his back turned so Sue didn't really know whether he had released the ball at the time of making contact. JWH had plenty of opportunity to pull out of his shot on Ponga and knew full well the ball had long ago been kicked and still went on with it.

How did you see the simms tackle on the 7. The one where the media was all over. Sims having to meet the 7 even before he had showered. Same tackle as jwh. But nothing

[Headless Chook]

How did you see the simms tackle on the 7. The one where the media was all over. Sims having to meet the 7 even before he had showered. Same tackle as jwh. But nothing

Didn't see it, so can't really comment.

[ism22]

TBH I can't recall either plays. I've just accepted that the refs were fair and moved on