Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Random option for hooker ?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Random option for hooker ?

    So, I know this may sound completely absurd and left-field but since Jake Friend will be out for another 6-8 weeks at least with an injury, the Roosters will have to implement another player as an interim hooker.

    The usual option would be to throw Victor Radley back into starting hooker but in the last few weeks his service out of dummy-half has been below average and he is better suited to play his preferred position as a Lock Forward and with the run into the finals getting close we need to make sure we win games and start to fine tune ourselves heading into the finals with the best 17 players available on the park. I believe that Sam Verrills would be a better option to play hooker with Radley as the on-field back up but if there is an issue with using Sam Verrills for whatever reason then what about “Joseph Manu” ?

    I know that sounds absolutely mental but Manu is just as big as Radley (body size comparison) and in the last few weeks he has built a bit of game mileage with playing at fullback plus he has decent speed and the odd sneaky step here and there so using that speed/skill out of dummy-half whilst attacking may not be a bad option. With that it also leaves the right edge backs of Brett Morris and Ryan Hall intact and the games they have played together in the last two weeks has been quite impressive. Both players are solid and reliable and it would be a shame to lose either Hall or Morris to the bench or Norths (honourable mention to Ikuvalu who has played well for the Roosters as a Winger this year as well).

    I know it’s not wise to use/play players out of positions especially if it’s very random but it’s just a thought and Manu played good against the Dogs a few weeks back as part of the spine (fullback) so why not up front instead ? I know it does burn more fuel, require more attention to detail, defend etc but hey we used a legitimate Lock Forward for several games who yes was a former a hooker but surely his dummy-half days are behind him and the Roosters have used a lot of players in various positions this year so far for example (Latrell, Aubbo, Radley, Manu, Morris) so whynot ?


    Thoughts ?
    Last edited by DP1990; 07-22-2019, 01:43 AM.

  • #2
    You’re right. That is absurd

    Comment


    • #3
      I started reading the post and was thinking " i bet Butcher gets suggested"...... but Manu? Yeah you got me.

      I hope Sam Verrills gets the job.....really looks the goods

      Comment


      • #4
        Manu’s defence is sus at the best of times.

        He cant pass right to left.

        Do you even watch the game?

        Comment


        • #5
          Last night on Matty Johns, Josh Hodgson mentioned he was first approached by Easts about being a second string hooker. Mostly playing NSW Cup so he wasn't into it.

          What might have been.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Bansai Pipeline View Post
            Last night on Matty Johns, Josh Hodgson mentioned he was first approached by Easts about being a second string hooker. Mostly playing NSW Cup so he wasn't into it.

            What might have been.
            he is way too good to be a second stringer.

            Comment


            • #7
              is it april 1
              1911 1912 1913 1923 1935 1936 1937 1940 1945 1974 1975 2002 2013 2018 2019 2020

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Thirteen View Post
                Manu’s defence is sus at the best of times.

                He cant pass right to left.

                Do you even watch the game?

                Hrmmm right so Manu "can't pass right to left" yet Robbo picked him as Fullback on two occasions recently and if that was also the case then he wouldn't have been picked to play for the Kiwis on more than one occasion now would he ?

                Here I thought I was the only one talking out on my ass !?

                Comment


                • #9
                  Manu at hooker, now that’s absurd. But, I do like the idea of Verrills starting and Rads being a backup.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by DP1990 View Post


                    Hrmmm right so Manu "can't pass right to left" yet Robbo picked him as Fullback on two occasions recently and if that was also the case then he wouldn't have been picked to play for the Kiwis on more than one occasion now would he ?

                    Here I thought I was the only one talking out on my ass !?
                    Have you watched his last game against the cowboys? He wouldn’t pass the freakin’ ball when we had overlaps.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      The only issue “may be” is that Sam Verrills was registered as a “development player” for the Sydney Roosters in 2019 and technically was not listed as part of the 30-man playing squad so I’m not quite sure but there may be an issue with him being promoted to the starting squad on a temporary-fulltime basis under the NRL rules and regulations.

                      I think this was also partially the issue that the Roosters had to deal with and realised hence why they reluctantly had to utilise Radley as starting hooker for 2+ months, otherwise Verrills looked much better and offered a better service out of dummy-half in comparison to Radley when he has played a few times so it didn’t make sense why they persisted with Radley as hooker for so long.

                      I could be wrong, if there’s someone out there that understand the rules with utilising players that aren’t listed as part of the 30-man playing squad then please feel free to chime in and inform us all...

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by OMR View Post

                        Have you watched his last game against the cowboys? He wouldn’t pass the freakin’ ball when we had overlaps.
                        Yes I did watch the game and I understand what you're referring to and my view is that he is a "glory hunter/hero" and likes to take on the line himself and attempt to score tries. There were so many moments in that game where he could have passed the ball to his inside/outside man and even in other games when he has usually played right-center on many occasions this season for example where he left the likes of Hall, Morris and Ikuvalu waiting thus ending up losing an opportunity to score points. He even did this a lot when he played with Fergo last season as well.

                        So I do agree that he is a bit of a ball hog and doesn't like to pass and places the ball in one hand tries to do a shimmy/step here and there in order to look fancy but that doesn't mean he can't pass at all !

                        The notion of passing/sharing the ball needs to be drilled into his head !

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          I would only go to the semis with rads at hooker ,young sam can have a go here and there
                          Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the universe

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            No I reckon we should stick Tedesco in there - his a stronger body shape can pass both ways and has good speed off the mark. Put manu back to fullback, aubbo to centre latrell to 5/8 hall to prop rotation and Cronk on the bench in case Cordner gets hurt.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by The Lip View Post
                              No I reckon we should stick Tedesco in there - his a stronger body shape can pass both ways and has good speed off the mark. Put manu back to fullback, aubbo to centre latrell to 5/8 hall to prop rotation and Cronk on the bench in case Cordner gets hurt.
                              Ha !

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X