Soo

[Jacks Fur Coat]

im not arguing that. Just reckon if he’s the best in the comp according to the dally m, surely he should start there? I too believe Luke is the better 5/8 so either the Dally Ms are wrong or the selections are wrong. In all honesty, I would like to see what Jack could have done with more ball in his hands but Luke did look good with his limited opportunities.

I thought Jack ran the ball well once or twice but his defence was atrocious except for one good hit.

You want to pick a team based on the very arbitrary Dally M points? The voting system is shite.

[rented tracksuit]

they were poor because they are not centers, wightons strength is his running game with the ball, he was redundant out there, NSW halves played an awful game, only looked threatening when walker chimes into the backline.

lomax should have been in the centers for king gutho.

Demoted from king to jester after that effort.

[Lydon]

Andrew Johns calling for Keary to be dropped next game for Cody Walker based on his vulnerability in defence on the edges..

Gee he hates us!

[King Salvo]

NSW wasted so many opportunities in that first half and it cost them - dont think there was any continuity in the backline or in attack - Cleary and Keary didn't wotk and Wighton and Gutho are not centres- Toops looked gassed in the second half and that pass - be sitting out game 2 along with Keary and Cordner

[Bruce Pickett]

I thought he and Cleary we dreadful and these two blokes were first and second fir the dally m as well. Unbelievable!

as much as we have shown our dislike for Luai over the past few weeks thanks to his antics, it’s obvious he makes Cleary look a LOT better than he really is.

Yep, Luai is a punk, but he does make Cleary look better.

[King Salvo]

Andrew Johns calling for Keary to be dropped next game for Cody Walker based on his vulnerability in defence on the edges..

Gee he hates us!

He is right though- Keary hasn't been the same since that Storm game - busted ribs and rushed to hospital game

[Big Dog]

NSW wasted so many opportunities in that first half and it cost them - dont think there was any continuity in the backline or in attack - Cleary and Keary didn't wotk and Wighton and Gutho are not centres- Toops looked gassed in the second half and that pass - be sitting out game 2 along with Keary and Cordner

I'd drop wighton and gutherson first. They were both out of their depth and just turnstiles in defence. Cords getting yet another head knock is a real concern.

[milanja]

NSW wasted so many opportunities in that first half and it cost them - dont think there was any continuity in the backline or in attack - Cleary and Keary didn't wotk and Wighton and Gutho are not centres- Toops looked gassed in the second half and that pass - be sitting out game 2 along with Keary and Cordner

Not sure why toops wasn’t in the sights of keary and cleary for a few bombs.

Jimmy Maloney would have won us that game, there was no control by our halves at all.

[ROC181]

Andrew Johns calling for Keary to be dropped next game for Cody Walker based on his vulnerability in defence on the edges..

Gee he hates us!

He's been pushing for Walker before the team was announced so now that NSW has lost then he feels vindicated...at the end of the day, Johns may be an immortal but as a tipster and coach, he is shit. He tipped the Broncos to win the comp,at Nine's staff comp he was like last, and was coaching Moses at half. All Fail!

[NorthChook]

Channel 9 rooster player ratings:

Teddy 8
Ran for over 200 metres and had a try assist in a polished performance.

Toops 6
Made plenty of ground but made a dreadful error to allow Munster to score a crucial try.

Keary 5
Didn't make the most of his long-awaited Origin debut, having a quiet game with little time or space to work in.

Cordner 5
Copped yet another head knock and had to go off for a HIA. Did well to come back to the trenches, but made little impact.

Gus 6
Plenty of effort when given his chance and got more game time than expected due to Murray's injury.

Friend 6
Worked hard in defence - as always - but lacked zip from dummy-half.

Collins 6
Wayne Bennett wanted impact from him when he came on - and he delivered.

[Lydon]

He's been pushing for Walker before the team was announced so now that NSW has lost then he feels vindicated...at the end of the day, Johns may be an immortal but as a tipster and coach, he is shit. He tipped the Broncos to win the comp,at Nine's staff comp he was like last, and was coaching Moses at half. All Fail!

Yes the agenda is very obvious

[stringaz]

Channel 9 rooster player ratings:

Teddy 8
Ran for over 200 metres and had a try assist in a polished performance.

Toops 6
Made plenty of ground but made a dreadful error to allow Munster to score a crucial try.

Keary 5
Didn't make the most of his long-awaited Origin debut, having a quiet game with little time or space to work in.

Cordner 5
Copped yet another head knock and had to go off for a HIA. Did well to come back to the trenches, but made little impact.

Gus 6
Plenty of effort when given his chance and got more game time than expected due to Murray's injury.

Friend 6
Worked hard in defence - as always - but lacked zip from dummy-half.

Collins 6
Wayne Bennett wanted impact from him when he came on - and he delivered.

Geez Friend a 6? I thought he was a 7 at worst, had a great game.

[The Brain]

Andrew Johns calling for Keary to be dropped next game for Cody Walker based on his vulnerability in defence on the edges..

Gee he hates us!

How's that The Dally M one let them through

[roosterproud]

Best on ground for me was 2poo

[Johnny Tobin]

Best on ground for me was 2poo

Until he cost NSW the game