Soo

[King Salvo]

NSW Chooks - Cords/Toops/Keary/Teddy - QLD Chooks - Collins/Friend

[Rooster1908]

To be honest probably only Collins has the form to be picked . None of the others unless your picking on reputation .

[Thirteen]

Boyd doesn’t owe the club anything and that’s the way it should be. Every minute he’s on the field he is putting every fibre of his being into the Roosters winning. Sure he missed a very important tackle last night but did everyone miss all the carries he took out of our end on 3rd or 4th tackle off the back of a slow play the ball where we were going nowhere and he picks up 12m and gives us a quick play the ball to save the set. It happened deadset 10 times last night. The club has people employed to make sure he is in a condition where he can take the field and give that sort of effort as many weeks of the year possible. And he’s delivered us two premierships in a row with his leadership and guts. He doesn’t owe anyone shit.

Yes sure Boyd puts in but the club pays his salary. He is no spring chicken and his body is deteriorating. Quitting origin would make him fresher for us.

[Thirteen]

NSW Chooks - Cords/Toops/Keary/Teddy - QLD Chooks - Collins/Friend

I’d put Wighton at 6. He’s better than Keary.

[Nigel Gaffey]

Boyd needs to step down now. I think he owes that to the club. He won’t.

The thing about boyd is that he’s playing busted. One week to the next is completely different. It’s like watching a captains knock one week turn into a heavyweight on the ropes the next.

I absolutely admire his courage. If the roosters hierarchy are fair dinkum about deep diving into a post season forensic analysis, he has to be on or nearing his use by date. In so many big games, he is missing tackles in the line. GF last year he got stepped by Wighton. He was at fault for Papaliis try yesterday with a missed legs tackle, second try was barely hitting second gear next to rapana during the break as well as involved in the Tapane try, missed him before Tapane brushed off Keary twice.

Throw in the amount of games he’s missed this season to play rep footy, I can’t see how he holds his place at the club if those at the top aren’t afraid to make the big decisions. The Roosters and the club have to come first

[elo]

Cordner, Crichton, Keary, Tedesco, Tupou will all be named in the NSW train-on squad later today.

This season never ends, 2021 will be another whaky comp.

[Danish]

Yes sure Boyd puts in but the club pays his salary. He is no spring chicken and his body is deteriorating. Quitting origin would make him fresher for us.

isnt he like 28? Hardly some old codger. He’s probably got 5 seasons to go

[milanja]

isnt he like 28? Hardly some old codger. He’s probably got 5 seasons to go

Boyd will look 80 in 5 years time.

[Big Dog]

Boyd needs to step down now. I think he owes that to the club. He won’t.

Careful, saying common sense things like this will get you labelled as a souffs supporter.

[Big Dog]

isnt he like 28? Hardly some old codger. He’s probably got 5 seasons to go

It's the head knocks. He had two bad ones this season alone. Many commentators have called for him to retire for the sake of his long term health. At the very least he shouldn't play SOO this year.

[Big Dog]

NSW Chooks - Cords/Toops/Keary/Teddy - QLD Chooks - Collins/Friend

I'd be happy to see Toops and Chrichton play for NSW and Collins and Friend for QLD. The others derserve, and need a decent rest.

[Mickie Lane]

Whats the story with Toups didnt he pledge his allegiance to Tonga?
Can he play SOO?

[Johnny Brass]

No way on form does Keary deserve to be picked ahead of Cody Walker or Wighton for origin since he busted his ribs.
Cords needs a rest and it's bordering on cruelty picking him after the head knocks he's copped at the end of the year.

[zac]

reports that nsw will add teddy, toops, keary, cordner and crichton to the nsw train on squad.

[Jacks Fur Coat]

Wish they would just forget about Origin this year, everyone has done enough. Players deserve a proper break.

I get it must be a $$ thing, but at least we got a full comp in this year.