Andrew Johns is a flop

[Rooster_6]

Suggesting NSW should drop Luke Keary.

The ch9 punditry is seriously at an all time low.

[NorthChook]

One of the worst commentators in the current line up - consistently makes poor predictions and stupid comments

[stringaz]

I've really gone off him this year, his honest disdain for the Roosters is one thing and then his idea of removing players from the field as the game goes on to "open it up" has me calling for the men in white coats.

Him saying keary should be dropped along with bringing papenhausen onto the bench for game 2 is ridiculous.

Put the bloke out to pasture.

[Mad_Rabid_Rooster]

It often seems he is half stung or under the influence of something. He adds very little commentary value IMHO.

[mattyh]

I'd personally would be happy if keary and cordner didn't play origin 2 and 3. but that's me being selfish. I actually sometimes find johns insightful the way he can explain a game and certain plays sometimes is great. but yea his tipping is shit, whenever he says so and so are specials put money on the other team.

[The Skeez]

Fittler has a 9 contract that the series must go to game free

[Kelvin Johnson]

Keary was poor and has been for most of the year. His defense is terrible and without Latrell he looks ordinary in attack.
Cordner is a liability I don't know how he can stay in the team.

[Johnny Brass]

Keary was firing on all cylinders early on in the year but I think he's lost a bit of confidence since he busted his ribs and isn't digging into the line with the same vigour.
Cords looks busted and keeps getting stepped , probably because he's thinking about where he puts his head.
I said it before this origin is the last thing our busted up team needs.

[dice]

NSW selectors cost the game. Walker a wasted bench spot which bit hard with Cam Murray injury. Wighton let in two tries by having to defend out of position. Playing Gutho out of position as well as though he is some superstar like Tommy Turbo that needed to be included in the side.

IMO if Wighton is fit to play then put him in his preferred spot at 5/8th. Find two specialist centres. Keary, Walker, and Gutho enjoy the offseason.

[milanja]

NSW selectors cost the game. Walker a wasted bench spot which bit hard with Cam Murray injury. Wighton let in two tries by having to defend out of position. Playing Gutho out of position as well as though he is some superstar like Tommy Turbo that needed to be included in the side.

IMO if Wighton is fit to play then put him in his preferred spot at 5/8th. Find two specialist centres. Keary, Walker, and Gutho enjoy the offseason.

In the second half, nsw only looked likely when walker was on the field.

cleary played without any authority and NSW gave away so much possession.

nsw missed Maloney the most.

[rented tracksuit]

In the second half, nsw only looked likely when walker was on the field.

cleary played without any authority and NSW gave away so much possession.

nsw missed Maloney the most.

Shame he would need two weeks quarantine or we could get him back Alfie style!

[Headless Chook]

People keep banging on about Wighton being played out of position but he played in the same spot last year and did fine, He just had a bad night last night.

[roosterproud]

Whighton and gutho were shit.
didnt use keary bombing to 2poo once.
All the attack was down adocars side.
Klearys kicking options were as good as the storm game.
qld scored nearly all their tries from errors. And they did the simple knees elbos quick play the balls in the 2nd half.

[Johnny Tobin]

In fairness he didn't exactly ignite the attack but Cleary is in the same boat.

[Headless Chook]

In fairness he didn't exactly ignite the attack but Cleary is in the same boat.

Definitely wasn't his best game, but two of their tries were scored because of missed tackles by our centres and apparenmtly Keary is 'vulnerable' in defence?