Player criticism

[DP1990]

No just dont like bullies and keyboard warriors. You probably never laced on a boot let alone played grade to know the pressure and sacrifice players make but think you know better than Robbo

Lol... I have played the game and laced up many boots on my feet from primary school years to my late teens ... have you ?


I've played the following and I am proud :

• Panther Trophy Rugby League Competition
• NSWCCC (NSW Combined Catholic Colleges)
• Metropolitan Cup
• Penrith District Junior Rugby League
• Parramatta Junior Rugby League

Do I consider myself as a bully or an arm-chair expert that knows more than Robbo ? nope. Do I think I have any idea of what a First Grade player goes thru in regards to pressure or sacrifice, also nope but I highly doubt you do either so reel it in, buddy because if there is anyone who is trying to act like a keyboard warrior, saviour, great hope or act in a prophetic role ... it's you !


In Robbo We Trust !

[rented tracksuit]

Never say never.
We can still win the comp this year...it is possible.
Unlikely, but still possible.
The GF is not until Oct.
Steven Bradbury made the final, and won a gold medal at the Olympics.

Run that race again and see what happens. Let me tell ya. Dogs, Donkeys and Tagpies are coming last and I bet all in front don't fall down.

[Lydon]

Should be asked already. There is no way in fuk we should be kept to 0 by any team, let alone a side we have on equal par with over the past 4 years. They were always going to win but not score a point is simply unacceptable. I expected us to at least have won a half.

I can’t disagree with you there..

[Rooster1908]

Lol... I have played the game and laced up many boots on my feet from primary school years to my late teens ... have you ?


I've played the following and I am proud :

• Panther Trophy Rugby League Competition
• NSWCCC (NSW Combined Catholic Colleges)
• Metropolitan Cup
• Penrith District Junior Rugby League
• Parramatta Junior Rugby League

Do I consider myself as a bully or an arm-chair expert that knows more than Robbo ? nope. Do I think I have any idea of what a First Grade player goes thru in regards to pressure or sacrifice, also nope but I highly doubt you do either so reel it in, buddy because if there is anyone who is trying to act like a keyboard warrior, saviour, great hope or act in a prophetic role ... it's you !


In Robbo We Trust !

Yep Aussie Rules for Coolamon Grasshoppers Juniors to First grade.
Switched to league at 18 and played Group 9 first grade for Turvey park then Tumut Blues.
Ended up playing in the pub league in Wagga at about 30 so year played some.
Again played as a team sport not a one man warrior like you Double

[DP1990]

Yep Aussie Rules for Coolamon Grasshoppers Juniors to First grade.
Switched to league at 18 and played Group 9 first grade for Turvey park then Tumut Blues.
Ended up playing in the pub league in Wagga at about 30 so year played some.
Again played as a team sport not a one man warrior like you Double

Ah right... now I see the problem that you have endured, and it gives me a better understanding to trace back and pin-point where your fascination/love for male genitalia all began ! … Aussie rules , I see ? … ha … GAY !

[Paddo Colt 61]

[QUOTE=Mickie Lane; Fark your a dreamer. The Chooks have as much chance of winning the comp this year as what the Tigers do.

Yep, the glass half empty is the go atm. They looked like the reserve graders that they are up against a dynamic professional side that has all of the details covered. They must be kings of the strip (how many were there last night?) and the challenge that regained possession is evidence of that not to mention the dispossession of poor ol' JWH after his intercept.
That a side can be flogged so comprehensively going back to the last round 2020 and on so many occasions since and still be in the eight is baffling and in no way a positive. I don't rate many of the years replacements - Lam is at the height of his powers, Fifita, Keighran and Egan are no more than average talents. Sualli and Walker are kids and certainly not yet the inspirations that some claim they are. The magic's gone. Bleak period ahead.

[Rooster1908]

Ah right... now I see the problem that you have endured, and it gives me a better understanding to trace back and pin-point where your fascination/love for male genitalia all began ! … Aussie rules , I see ? … ha … GAY !

Yeah that's a good one , not as good a game to play but a lot more skill involved.Prefered league but .You know the old saying , one man trying to shove two men's heads up three mens bums , did it for me .see I can self degrade myself , don't need your pompus ass to do it

[DP1990]

Yeah that's a good one , not as good a game to play but a lot more skill involved.Prefered league but .You know the old saying , one man trying to shove two men's heads up three mens bums , did it for me .see I can self degrade myself , don't need your pompus ass to do it

Cmon mate.... lol ... 18 blokes in one team running around in circles and kicking a ball thru three posts on either end with scores climbing up in total like a 1 800 --- --- phone number ? ... a lot more skill involved ... SURELY NOT !

1. Rugbah Leeg
2. MMA (UFC)

3. Daylight

..................

4. Yawnion
5. Cricket
6. Soccer
7 Gayfl


How dare you bring my ass into disrepute !?

[Rooster1908]

Cmon mate.... lol ... 18 blokes in one team running around in circles and kicking a ball thru three posts on either end with scores climbing up in total like a 1 800 --- --- phone number ? ... a lot more skill involved ... SURELY NOT !

1. Rugbah Leeg
2. MMA (UFC)

3. Daylight

..................

4. Yawnion
5. Cricket
6. Soccer
7 Gayfl


How dare you bring my ass into disrepute !?

I think its a bit like everything else you have been talking about . You haven't actually done it so you probably wouldn't know. But there again is something else we agree on. League . not Rugbah is the best game

[DP1990]

I think its a bit like everything else you have been talking about . You haven't actually done it so you probably wouldn't know. But there again is something else we agree on. League . not Rugbah is the best game

Wrong again with your unsubstantiated assumptions . I've played/competed in League, MMA, Cricket and even Soccer but what would you know ? Your head's so far up your ass all you end up doing is eating/shitting out the same old lame comments with no punchline.


Almost played Union for the Western Raptors (formerly known as the Rooty Hill Raptors) in 2006 as I was scouted but I turned it down as I preferred League … no way would I ever play AFL, can’t even stand the bloody thing on TV.


Have a good day, chump

[Vasco]

Here's my take.

1. Teddy - tried too hard. Buzzing in the first half but became uninspired and frustrated with the teams collective performance around him.
2. Sualii - bright future, but shows lack of match experience..it will come. I really enjoy watching him play. Great future.
3. JMoz - off night, but still a solid defensive center. Attacking wise, he is off the pace against the top sides.
4. Manu - we all expect better from him. He is no longer the #1 center in the game. That goes to Olam. too inconsistent in my opinion.
5. Toops - tried hard, always does. One of our positives.
6. Walker - tried too hard but not his night. Plenty for him to takeaway and learn from last night. He will be better for it. Defensively still a concern.
7. Lam - Needs to be dropped. Offers nothing in attack. Weak defensively. I think he played his last game for the tricolors
8. JWH - He is taking up the workload for an out of form SST
9. Verills - supposed to be 'the artist'. Was a 5/10 last night and we need him to be a consistent 7-8/10 each week.
10. SST - completely out of form. Needs a kick up the backside. His running meters are decent but he's not a bully. Doesn't bend the line at all in attack. No quick play the balls.
11. Gus - tried hard but our whole pack was dominated. Good running battle with kafusi. We miss radley
12. Sitili - good first half but dropped ball on half time summed up our poor half overall. Ran for 27m which is completely ridiculous for a player of his potential.
13. Liu - might be time to send him off to titans if rumours are true...wondering if he did reveal he is leaving on match day to the boys. That would really p1ss me off!

E Butcher - plenty of upside
Fifita - cheap shot merchant. Needs to be dropped to the bears
Baker - good young player. Not sure why he doesn't get more minutes.
Hutchison - good to see him back. Not sure he is what we need but he's a tough player just to be back on the field he should be commended.

Hard to argue with these scores.

Sitili has gone backwards as the season has progressed. I'm not convinced he's an 80 minute edge player.

Better off coming from the bench and using his speed, power and footwork around the middle of the park.

[Rooster1908]

Wrong again with your unsubstantiated assumptions . I've played/competed in League, MMA, Cricket and even Soccer but what would you know ? Your head's so far up your ass all you end up doing is eating/shitting out the same old lame comments with no punchline.


Almost played Union for the Western Raptors (formerly known as the Rooty Hill Raptors) in 2006 as I was scouted but I turned it down as I preferred League … no way would I ever play AFL, can’t even stand the bloody thing on TV.


Have a good day, chump

Talking about Aussie Rules weren't we , oh dear , keep up.Have you missed your nap or medication

[DP1990]

Talking about Aussie Rules weren't we , oh dear , keep up.Have you missed your nap or medication

Disregard my previous comment. That was an unwarranted attack (reply).


Nap ? Meds ? nope … maybe some remnants of anger and alcohol from last night’s game (performance).


Aussie Rules is shit. Case closed.

[Rooster1908]

Here's my take.

1. Teddy - tried too hard. Buzzing in the first half but became uninspired and frustrated with the teams collective performance around him.
2. Sualii - bright future, but shows lack of match experience..it will come. I really enjoy watching him play. Great future.
3. JMoz - off night, but still a solid defensive center. Attacking wise, he is off the pace against the top sides.
4. Manu - we all expect better from him. He is no longer the #1 center in the game. That goes to Olam. too inconsistent in my opinion.
5. Toops - tried hard, always does. One of our positives.
6. Walker - tried too hard but not his night. Plenty for him to takeaway and learn from last night. He will be better for it. Defensively still a concern.
7. Lam - Needs to be dropped. Offers nothing in attack. Weak defensively. I think he played his last game for the tricolors
8. JWH - He is taking up the workload for an out of form SST
9. Verills - supposed to be 'the artist'. Was a 5/10 last night and we need him to be a consistent 7-8/10 each week.
10. SST - completely out of form. Needs a kick up the backside. His running meters are decent but he's not a bully. Doesn't bend the line at all in attack. No quick play the balls.
11. Gus - tried hard but our whole pack was dominated. Good running battle with kafusi. We miss radley
12. Sitili - good first half but dropped ball on half time summed up our poor half overall. Ran for 27m which is completely ridiculous for a player of his potential.
13. Liu - might be time to send him off to titans if rumours are true...wondering if he did reveal he is leaving on match day to the boys. That would really p1ss me off!

E Butcher - plenty of upside
Fifita - cheap shot merchant. Needs to be dropped to the bears
Baker - good young player. Not sure why he doesn't get more minutes.
Hutchison - good to see him back. Not sure he is what we need but he's a tough player just to be back on the field he should be commended.

Agree with this 100% but why only lam to be dropped , our forwards where dominated , our back where out classed and this has been the case for weeks , dropping just Lam changes nothing as did dropping Matt

[Rooster1908]

Disregard my previous comment. That was an unwarranted attack (reply).


Nap ? Meds ? nope … maybe some remnants of anger and alcohol from last night’s game (performance).


Aussie Rules is shit. Case closed.

All good have a great evening .And y s agree , Rules us shit , but so is soccer .Oh and mixed netball lol