The player who disappointed you the most?

[Headless Chook]

You forget that these things are all relative. We'd not been able to attract any big names for years, hence the reason we signed Phil Gould at the end of 1994. Fittler was a HUGE signing. A once in a generation signing. But O'Donnell was a big signing, probably our biggest for 5 long seasons.

Guess we all remember things differently. I would have said that Darren Junee, Graham Mackay, Tony Iro and Andrew Walker were bigger names than him at the time

[Roosta4life]

It’s a general question that was asked. It’s not necessarily about player ability. I was bitterly disappointed when RTS left.

Fair enough- we all were. Incredible player.

[Rooster90]

Josh Lewis

Was still playing for Hills Bulls this year, which is technically our 3rd grade squad due to their association with the Bears

[Ray Stehr]

Bob McCarthy.

[The Bondi spy]

Matt Burke and his brother brad. Barely fired a shot between them. Did own a good pub though!

[Tom Verlaine's Ghost]

Guess we all remember things differently. I would have said that Darren Junee, Graham Mackay, Tony Iro and Andrew Walker were bigger names than him at the time

Indeed we must - because O'Donnell signed before all those people.

[Waylander]

Mona El Ahmed

[Cyril Snodgrass III]

Latrell "Jaws" Mitchell

[Rocky Rhodes]

Surely Shitchell Pearce gets a mention.....talked up to be the next A Johns...ended up been more like Brett Finch, which might be an insult to Fnchy himself.

All Poms except Morley and Joe Lydon..

Sandy Campbell, Mick Delroy...absolute duds hehe

Willie Mason & O'Meley

More to come..

[John Corey]

Sandy Campbell. Had an amazing year at the Dogs. Was a lean flyer. We threw big bucks at him and he turned up here with muscles on his muscles. Lost all speed and did F all for us. Someone later told me he started modelling in the off season so he built himself up.

[Headless Chook]

Indeed we must - because O'Donnell signed before all those people.

Iro I got wrong but all the others debuted the same season as O'Donnell.

[Blue Suede Schubert]

My god, this is such a hard question to answer because there have been quite a few.

[The Bondi spy]

Remember Jason Williams? I’m sure we signed him because he made one great run for west’s in a midweek cup game. Did well for the dogs but yeh

[Ivan Benko]

That one signing who you expected to kill it for us…but never delivered at all. Mine would be john Simon. Unstoppable at the Steelers and played mainly reserves for roosters. Thoughts?

Rocky Laurie

[Johnny Tobin]

Brian Battese.