WTF Robbo - Lam on for 90% of the game and Walker on for 10% of the game?

[dice]

Wont be more than a grade 1 if charged - be a fine

https://www.nrl.com/news/2021/09/11/...tact-on-kelly/

Is it considered a Shoulder Charge? If so Grade 1 is 200 points.

[SamKerrSimp]

Absolutely. That game in warm conditions on a fast hard track really took its toll. All the boys had to dig deep and deserve due credit. Esp those playing big minutes.

This is why that unnecessary outside inside play on half way with 12 to go and leading by 6 pissed me off so much: Titans were shot, the set before they were standing still going nowhere and we were marching up the field all we had to do was keep taking the hitups and we had them; we gift them an error back in the game, they put pressure on us and Lam passes to Iku's shoulder and that stupid try is conceded. They had the belief and the momentum after that but luckily their 10 wins for the season shone through and they gifted us ample opportunity to win the game, anyone else in the top 6 would've finished us from that position.

[King Salvo]

Is it considered a Shoulder Charge? If so Grade 1 is 200 points.

It wasn't a shoulder charge- Dangerous contact head or neck or careless high tackle- the grading will be the question if charged.

Radley was charged with a grade 2 careless high tackle in a similar tackle - why it was a grade 2 as it was deemed he launched himself at TPJ

Yeo on report for a crusher that's 1 game if charged- Riff looked very rattled and frustrated - if they lose they play winner of Eels vs Knights and if they win then Melbourne

[zac]

Is it considered a Shoulder Charge? If so Grade 1 is 200 points.

doesn't look like a shoulder charge to me - the main contact was with sam's collarbone - there's more contact between the two of their heads than there is on sam's shoulder

[zac]

It wasn't a shoulder charge- Dangerous contact head or neck

if the main force isn't on the shoulder then i don't see a problem. kelly's head hit verrills' torso.

[Johnny Brass]

It wasn't a shoulder charge- Dangerous contact head or neck or careless high tackle- the grading will be the question if charged.

Radley was charged with a grade 2 careless high tackle in a similar tackle - why it was a grade 2 as it was deemed he launched himself at TPJ

Yeo on report for a crusher that's 1 game if charged- Riff looked very rattled and frustrated - if they lose they player winner of Eels vs Knights and if they win then Melbourne

Marshke will be playing next week

[The Lip]

you hate each win this team has

? ?? ?

[King Salvo]

Lam sucks.
If he starts next week I’m not watching

Plus, to those who say Walker is a worse defender than Lam are plain dumb. 5 games into his career you’re probably right, but now he’s improved tremendously. Lam falls off every tackle

Lammy made 23 tackles so obviously not falling off tackles

[King Salvo]

if the main force isn't on the shoulder then i don't see a problem. kelly's head hit verrills' torso.

Gould's saying it should be treated the same as Mitchell's tackle on Manu as Kelly Broke his nose.- Johns is saying Verrills wont be playing next week

[ROC181]

Lammy made 23 tackles so obviously not falling off tackles

Yeah he's a tackling machine!

[SamKerrSimp]

Gould's saying it should be treated the same as Mitchell's tackle on Manu as Kelly Broke his nose.- Johns is saying Verrills wont be playing next week

If you wanted to give rugby league an enema you'd stick the hose through the channel 9 commentary team

[night_shadow]

Personally, I think Robbo is quietly protecting Sam. We've had so many injuries this year. It would be devastating for him to suffer a serious injury and put 2022 in jeopardy.

[Johnny Brass]

Gould's saying it should be treated the same as Mitchell's tackle on Manu as Kelly Broke his nose.- Johns is saying Verrills wont be playing next week

For some reason Gus has turned on us, he seems to have become quite contrary to the roosters it seems to have coincided with the love we have been receiving from Buzz and Kent over on Fox.

[Team Evil]

Watch the short clip of that last play. Walker runs out of the line and tackles nobody to create the overlap, and then runs back in the line and gets palmed off. That is what Robbo sees. Of course, everyone else only sees the "season-saving tackle!"

Sam Walker makes a season-saving tackle! - NRL

Yep.

[King Salvo]

Yeah he's a tackling machine!

JWH made 23 tackles as well- Toops is listed as 0 tackles