Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Artie Snubed.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    SMH article

    For three decades, Souths and Roosters icon Ron Coote has been excluded from rugby league’s most exclusive club, the Immortals, much to his disappointment.

    But the towering lock-forward can soon take comfort in having a grandstand named after him in the new $828 million Sydney Football Stadium.

    Coote’s name will sit alongside two fellow sporting giants in the world-class arena, which is on track for completion in August.

    Late Socceroos legend Johnny Warren and Wallaby great Sir Nicholas Shehadie, the former ARU chairman and SCG Trustee critical in the building of the first SFS in 1988, will also be recognised.

    A fourth stand will curiously be named the Garrison Stand, which acknowledges the historical significance of the precinct when British Army Soldiers played cricket on a stretch of turf that later became known as the Sydney Cricket Ground.

    While that decision is sure to confuse many patrons, Coote’s inclusion has already raised the ire of his former team, the Roosters, who argued to Venues NSW that Immortal Arthur Beetson should have been named ahead of him.

    Coote played in nine grand finals over 11 seasons from 1965, winning four with South Sydney before controversially linking with foundation club arch-rivals Eastern Suburbs, playing for the Tri-colours in their 1974 and 1975 premierships.

    Beetson was the captain of both those sides and the Roosters claim his status as an Immortal — something Coote has not achieved since the concept’s inception in 1980 — should put him ahead of his former teammate.
    Advertisement
    Other powerbrokers want former Roosters and NSW captain Brad Fittler acknowledged because of his appeal to a younger generation.

    The SCG Heritage Trust was charged with the onerous responsibility of naming the stands in the 45,000-seat facility.

    Members of the trust include prominent businessman Maurice Newman and former SCG Trustee Rodney Cavalier.

    All tenants of the Moore Park precinct, including the Sydney Swans who don’t play on a rectangular stadium, were invited to put forward names.

    A shortlist was drawn before the Heritage Trust made a recommendation to the Venues NSW board.

    It is understood Coote was endorsed for two reasons.

    First, the belief that his playing achievements have been under-recognised by rugby league, although he has been inducted into the game’s Hall of Fame. Apart from Coote’s premiership success for Souths and the Roosters, he played 23 Tests for Australia.

    Second, he was the founder of the Men of League Foundation, which has provided invaluable support for former players, coaches and officials who have fallen on hard times since its inception in 2000.

    The Roosters refused to comment on the record, nor did Venues NSW, but privately the club believes their recommendation should hold greater weight because they are the ground’s oldest tenants, having played out of the former Sydney Sportsground since 1911 before it was replaced by the first incarnation of the SFS, which it also called home until its demolition in 2018.

    While Beetson has been overlooked this time, he could be named on a grandstand in the future. There are a further four naming positions yet to be decided.

    It has also been speculated the Roosters’ centre of excellence inside the new stadium could bear his name, although there will be a strong push for the club’s long-serving chairman and benefactor, Nick Politis.

    Recognising history is often a thankless task for administrators, especially when so many clubs and codes share the venue. Rarely do people agree on the naming of grandstands or erection of statues.

    Warren’s inclusion doesn’t just recognise his contribution to football, but football’s link to the Sydney Sportsground, where the Socceroos played most of their matches because it was a flatter, truer surface than the SCG.

    Shehadie’s name adorned one of the stands in the old SFS, but the Heritage Trust considered his contribution too great to not use again.

    The Roosters and South Sydney are expected to play the first match at the stadium when they meet in Round 25 on September 2 despite lobbying from the Matildas, Wallabies and Sydney FC.

    Comment


    • #17
      Artie was a legend at the SCG pitch, that is for sure. Although I agree with everyone's thoughts I actually think the stands should be named after legends who actually played on that surface.

      Thinking Ricketson, Minichiello (One club players & Premiership winners), Michael Hooper (Waratahs 2014 Captain & Wallaby) and Craig Coleman...... That's just me no doubt everyone will not agree

      Comment


      • #18
        Originally posted by Nathan Aboud View Post
        Artie was a legend at the SCG pitch, that is for sure. Although I agree with everyone's thoughts I actually think the stands should be named after legends who actually played on that surface.

        Thinking Ricketson, Minichiello (One club players & Premiership winners), Michael Hooper (Waratahs 2014 Captain & Wallaby) and Craig Coleman...... That's just me no doubt everyone will not agree
        Sounds like there's 4 more stands and this wasn't necessarily a snubbing. Guess we'll see who else gets named (although I suspect soccer and yawnion fans will get their shot at it).

        Comment


        • #19
          Got no problems with it being named after Ron Coote. He is a Rooster's legend and should be an Immortal. Webster is just trying to create mischief by saying Easts fans resent it. I'm sure 99.9% Easts fans support the Ron Coote stand.

          Comment


          • #20
            It was only going to be one stand named after a rugby league player and because they want the filth to play there too Ron Coote was the obvious choice or I should say the political choice. The British Army stand is something they must have plucked out of the air to show they didn't favor one code over the other.

            The SCG trust forget that we are the only club that has never left the ground and Webby for some reason has gone off the roosters big time and firmly in the filths corner.

            .

            Comment


            • #21
              [QUOTE=kakaruk; Who are these committee members that made these decisions?

              The Tories do the naming as usual. The Ferry McFerryface people. Nick Shehadie - Tory and RU man. Not a luminary in any way. Will fit in nicely with the Rugby Union museum however.

              Comment


              • #22
                [QUOTE=Paddo Colt 61;n917634][QUOTE=kakaruk; Who are these committee members that made these decisions?

                The Tories do the naming as usual. The Ferry McFerryface people. Nick Shehadie - Tory and RU man. Not a luminary in any way. Will fit in nicely with the Rugby Union museum however.

                [/QUOTE]

                Give it up mate, this is a nonpolitical discussion. Go joint Tim Blair that should be interesting for you.

                Comment


                • #23
                  Arthur Beetson Stadium it shall be then

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Ron Coote is a Roosters legend who, if not for Souths using their influence with the NSWRL to get the residential borders changed, would've played his entire career at Easts, where he was waiting to follow in his father's footsteps. I have no problem with him being honoured and no doubt Artie will be as well. I tried rebuffing a Souffs numnut sprouting the usual lies in the comments section, but of course they always ignore the truth when it comes to the Roosters - it sells more papers that way.

                    The whole 'Immortal' thing is a joke, really. For a start the name itself is completely over the top and smacks of hubris. Just have a Hall of Fame....an ACTUAL HALL OF FAME, PHYSICALLY LOCATED SOMEWHERE!... and do away with the best of the best rubbish.

                    Comment


                    • #25
                      Originally posted by NorfolkStreetKid View Post

                      Probably because Coote played 9 Grand Finals in11 years AT THE SCG and is both a Roosters and Souths legend. Great choice.
                      good to get the perspective of those who watched him play.

                      Was he a controversial signing for the chooks as Latrell will forever be seen by going to Souths? Or was he more in the Cronk mould where it looks like he just belonged all along?


                      Comment


                      • #26
                        Originally posted by Easts75 View Post

                        Fark no...the bloke is a flog
                        Deadset Mug, they should name the shithouses after him, as well as the Tab outlet if they have one. Blew most of his money on the punt which is why we still have to put up with his pathetic commetary.

                        Comment


                        • #27
                          Originally posted by Insider View Post

                          Deadset Mug, they should name the shithouses after him, as well as the Tab outlet if they have one. Blew most of his money on the punt which is why we still have to put up with his pathetic commetary.
                          They should name the shithouses after him..
                          #We Stand with ourJewish community#

                          Comment


                          • #28
                            Originally posted by Thirteen View Post
                            Shit stand names.
                            I think the names are fine as representing the 3 main footy codes, which I guess will all be played there, and a link to the areas history. I am happily surprised that there are no stands dedicated to Aboriginal CULTURE, or Gays. I am sick of tugging the proverbial forelock to minorities. But it won't surprise me if they do come up with some rubbish like this in the future.

                            Comment


                            • #29
                              I have no problem with the names, it's not our stadium so having League, Union and Soccer links is fine and the war links is better then some other PC links they could of included.
                              Ron is a good choice, played for Souths and Easts which ties both clubs into the naming, I'm sure if they picked a Souths legend as the name we would be more up in arms.

                              What names does the new Parramatta Stadium have, I have never paid attention but I don't think it would be just Eels greats.

                              Comment


                              • #30
                                Originally posted by Kentucky_Fried_Rooster View Post
                                I have no problem with the names, it's not our stadium so having League, Union and Soccer links is fine and the war links is better then some other PC links they could of included.
                                Ron is a good choice, played for Souths and Easts which ties both clubs into the naming, I'm sure if they picked a Souths legend as the name we would be more up in arms.

                                What names does the new Parramatta Stadium have, I have never paid attention but I don't think it would be just Eels greats.
                                It seems strange accounting for Souths wishes in what is essentially our stadium? (at least the League side of it). I'm sure there's no Easts stands etc. at Redfern Oval or their new stadium if they ever get one.

                                It's old Sports Ground land...Easts turf in other words.

                                They should piss off and develop their own dunghill.
                                #We Stand with ourJewish community#

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X