Players you expected big things from but never delivered?

[ccfc bondi]

I thought we'd be unbeatable when we signed Wallabies Ken Wright, and later Brett Papworth!

Was looking forward to seeing Fatty Vautin as well, but he turned out to be worse than disappointing. He never even looked interested!

[Headless Chook]

I remember a time when Phil Clarke was the only guy in the backline capable of making a break. He had speed and skill - just didn't get any media attention.

You're thinking of Peter Clarke. Phil was a Pommy international back rower

[Mickie Lane]

O’Sullivan, played one game for us and that was it. I thought he looked alright in that game.

O’Sullivan is a very good organizing number 7 with a excellent kicking game IMO. He had a top game last night & if the Dogs were watching I’d go after him if I was them.

[Rooster90]

Setaimata Sa.

Thought he had all the talent in the world.

Same with Samisoni Langi, wasn't he traded from the Dogs for Sam Perrett?

[Rooster90]

O’Sullivan is a very good organizing number 7 with a excellent kicking game IMO. He had a top game last night & if the Dogs were watching I’d go after him if I was them.

Pretty sure he will be the starting 7 at the Dolphins next year...

[ism22]

O’Sullivan is a very good organizing number 7 with a excellent kicking game IMO. He had a top game last night & if the Dogs were watching I’d go after him if I was them.

I wasn't particularly impressed. Despite Manly having some shocking calls go against them (two in try scoring situations), the scoreboard only really opened up towards the end when Manly were jiggered.

IMO Walker and Keary are both significantly better than SOS... who we only signed because he's POS' son.

[Helen of Troy]

Ryan Williamson

He is a great guy, awesome father, comes from a great family. I interviewed him when he arrived at the Roosters. But for me JP du Plessis. Outside of the Roosters the hilarious play out of Greg Smith at the Knights. It still makes me laugh.

[Mickie Lane]

I wasn't particularly impressed. Despite Manly having some shocking calls go against them (two in try scoring situations), the scoreboard only really opened up towards the end when Manly were jiggered.

IMO Walker and Keary are both significantly better than SOS... who we only signed because he's POS' son.

Firstly I’m not comparing O’Sullivan to Keary or Walker
Secondly the Panthers were the ones robbed of 2 tries.

[Random Rooster]

Cam Cherry
Alan Neil
Clinton O'Brien
The Sorenson brothers
Brad Tassell
John Simon
Dallas Hood
Paul Mares
Mick Delroy
James Pickering
Eric Grothe Jnr
Justin Carney
Dale Copley

[rented tracksuit]

3 players who didn't really deliver at our club ( or maybe weren't given enough time to develop or crack a permanent first grade spot ) then went on to bigger and better things at other clubs.

Nathan Blacklock
Ricky Walford
Adam MacDougall

That’s because he wasn’t on the gear whilst with us.

[rented tracksuit]

O’Sullivan is a very good organizing number 7 with a excellent kicking game IMO. He had a top game last night & if the Dogs were watching I’d go after him if I was them.

Absolutely. It’s the key they are missing there. All their big signings and they still appear rudderless.

[Nicola Tesla]

Sam Obst is a good one...I never thought he was going to be special but Artie sure loved him!
Soward also.... loved watching that Presidents Cup team and looked forward to his arrival in first grade, but was never given a go, attitude problems I heard... was good and one a comp but never great!
Papworth showed glimpses of brilliance but just never could stay on the field... he is one player I would have loved to have seen prosper!

So many others listed made me giggle... the memories!

[rented tracksuit]

Firstly I’m not comparing O’Sullivan to Keary or Walker
Secondly the Panthers were the ones robbed of 2 tries.

I wouldn’t say they were robbed at all but I will say it was just jumping practice for Luai and a few of his mates.

[rented tracksuit]

Cam Cherry
Alan Neil
Clinton O'Brien
The Sorenson brothers
Brad Tassell
John Simon
Dallas Hood
Paul Mares
Mick Delroy
James Pickering
Eric Grothe Jnr
Justin Carney
Dale Copley

Copley was my pick as well.

[QWERTY]

Firstly I’m not comparing O’Sullivan to Keary or Walker
Secondly the Panthers were the ones robbed of 2 tries.

I thought O’Sullivan’s passing game was top notch yesterday. That pass when he put Critchton through was outstanding. Took a lot of pressure of Luai as well