Should we sign SBW?

[milanja]

So where is this nursery that we can get all our talent from?

N.Z

[chook 56]

N.Z

Sorry, nothing but sheep left there.

[Guest]

The issue with this poll is a simple yes or no is not sufficient. Many on here want him signed, but not at say $800k a year. Many of those that don't want him aren't basing their opinion on his ability, it is purely on the amount of money they believe he will request. (There are of course those that don't want him regardless of how cheap he could come).

Maybe the poll should be:

No
Yes <$500k
Yes $501k to $600k
Yes $600k to $700k
etc

[Guest]

Those who think SBWalkout is going to give us a premiership should rethink their position. Souths tried it with Inglis. Thats worked really well hasnt it!?!?!

[Guest]

Those who think SBWalkout is going to give us a premiership should rethink their position. Souths tried it with Inglis. Thats worked really well hasnt it!?!?!

Lang was the bigger problem.

[007]

Can someone please tell me over the past 20 years how many 'even reasonable' ex dogs players the Roosters have signed have been worthwhile when they got here? I can think of 4 straight away that aren't/weren't any good; Mason, O'Meley, Anasta and Kouparidiot.
Who's next? Michael Ennis?

[chook 56]

Can someone please tell me over the past 20 years how many 'even reasonable' ex dogs players the Roosters have signed have been worthwhile when they got here? I can think of 4 straight away that aren't/weren't any good; Mason, O'Meley, Anasta and Kouparidiot.
Who's next? Michael Ennis?

If that grub comes here, that is the last straw

[mightyrooster]

No !

[Guest]

yes

[Guest]

I don't think I need to reiterate my feelings on the subject, though I will.

[Guest]

Maybe the poll should be:

No
Yes <$500k
Yes $501k to $600k
Yes $600k to $700k
etc

Agree with this. Working on Dubais poll I would go yes at 500 to 600, with details favouring us (injuries through boxing compensation, quiting fee etc etc).

[Guest]

We will never learn.

[Guest]

Yes Yes Yes.

[chook 56]

I don't think I need to reiterate my feelings on the subject, though I will.

I couldn't quite read that, John.
Could you repeat.
Just to get our message across

[redwhiteblue]