Who do you rate as the Roosters Big Three?

[Spanner in the works]

Here lies the problem. Our club talks abou 100% commitment. Geez our club has alot of those players. Few with 100% class.

I agree. It's all about balance. We don't need many superstars in the SBW mould, but we do need a couple to be competitive. Every team does. There is a reason they take up so much of your cap space. It's not like it is distributed unfairly.

[Guest]

Exactly. That's why I don't lay the blame solely on Brian Smith. He simply doesn't have the cattle to work with.

True that. He has not cattle, and even if he did, he wouldn't know how to get them on the boat ti indonesia.

His job has bee to build a young squad and get rid of the dead wood. Another year and he should pass the baton to a coach.

[horrie hastings]

Here lies the problem. Our club talks abou 100% commitment. Geez our club has alot of those players. Few with 100% class.

I would take a drinking Jennings, Carney, or overweight Inglis in a heartbeat.

Yeah i would have Carney back ,the 2010 version at least.Jennings yes.

[Guest]

My spelling is up there with stevey boy.

[Ray Stehr]

ATM Maubs, Mortimer and Cordner are the only players who can hold their head up high, the rest are pathetic

[Guest]

At the moment the players that can change a game, in know particular order would be;
SKD
JWH
TAKA

[Guest]

For me at the moment it is in no particular order;

SKD
PEARCE
JWH

Having said that like many I am not happy with that. I am hoping for;

NEW STAR FULLBACK
MALONEY
PEARCE
SBW

How about that? 4 big players + guys like SKD, Friend, Mortimer????, JWH, Kennedy, Taka, a firing Mose (we all know he is better than the crap he has offered thus far this season). Sounds fearsome to me.

[xavier]

Uncle Nick
Bouris
Gyngell

And if the players were just as shrewd and clinical in their performances as these guys are in business maybe we would win more games

[Guest]

Anasta, Mini and JWH

The importance of 2 of them not resigning and the other not being overpaid will determine next years squad.

[Geohood]

Maubs
Pearce
SKD

Them combining successfully will be biggest hope we have for this year.

The one's I hope will make a huge difference for next year include:
SBW
Maloney
Sheck
Moga

I really hope the latter 2 prove to have talent and aren't built up to no avail.

[Guest]

Anasta, Mini and JWH

The importance of 2 of them not re-signing and the other not being overpaid will determine next years squad.

Re-signing not resigning.

Means two different things.

[stsae]

Nice thread General, make em get out of their comfort zones, the softcocks.

Maubs our best player in attack and defence, hopefully next years captain.
JWH, stepped up before his time this year IMO.
Pearce, busts his arse and is on his own in running things sadly.

I gotta admit it was hard to pick the 3rd, Cordner and Pezzdispenser were close to Pearce for me. SKiD is too rocks and diamonds.

[Guest]

(6) carney,(13) anasta--------2013 (6)maloney,(13)sonnybill......im happy with that swap anyday

[Guest]

Mr Kennedy
Friendy
Aubo

[Hawkeye]

It should be
Anasta / Pearce / Mini

But I think its
Pearce / JWH / Jake