If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
It’s an interesting idea but not sure it works on a couple of levels
Top 4 teams who lose the first week should travel to the elimination final winners the next?
Well if you finish 3rd or 4th your reward is to play either of the two best teams in the comp away… so odds are you are going to lose… so then you should again travel away the next week to a team you finished above on the table after 24 rounds?
The teams 5 to 8 are playing lesser opponents the first week. So finish 5th and you’re likely to get two finals at home… finish 4th and you’re likely to get two finals away. Doesn’t make a great deal of sense
As for an extra week… how many times do you want to see these teams play each other before they meet in the Grand Final? Do you really want to see the two top 4 winners in week 1 play each other for a place in the GF…and then likely play each other again 2 weeks later in the actual GF?
That’s why they flip the rankings after week 1… they don’t want to see the same teams play each more than once if they can avoid it
Interesting idea nevertheless
I don’t mind the finals as they are… I’d probably prefer if they returned to a more typically seeded approach though… 1 vs 8… 2 vs 7 etc. but whatever it’s good
There’s a good reason they got rid of the lower teams hosting second week finals (under the old McIntyre system at least). It killed us in 2008 when we travelled to NZ second week to play the eighth placed Warriors. And also the minor premier dragons the following year went out in straight sets, the second game being away in Brisbane.
on no planet should Parra have had to play in Canberra last night.
Originally posted by SupermanSupportsEasts4EvaView Post
A Rabbitoh would sell rabbit meat back in the day. Now the vermin nick name themselves "the bunnies." Anyone else see the stupidity in that?
Yep exactly I know. But the TV broadcast (Foxtel) has no idea what sound to use which is appropriate for it, because there is none. We get a Roosters crow for instance and the Sharks Jaws music. So consequently we end up with the vermins club song!
Yep exactly I know. But the TV broadcast (Foxtel) has no idea what sound to use which is appropriate for it, because there is none. We get a Roosters crow for instance and the Sharks Jaws music. So consequently we end up with the vermins club song!
There’s a good reason they got rid of the lower teams hosting second week finals (under the old McIntyre system at least). It killed us in 2008 when we travelled to NZ second week to play the eighth placed Warriors. And also the minor premier dragons the following year went out in straight sets, the second game being away in Brisbane.
on no planet should Parra have had to play in Canberra last night.
the finals set up is pretty spot on as it is now
It made more sense with the old seeding system… 1 v 8… 2 v 7 etc… but it still diminished results over the season
If you just scrape into the finals after 24 matches don’t see there is a scenario where you should be hosting any finals
Originally posted by SupermanSupportsEasts4EvaView Post
Most of those 80k supporters at the first 2 games were Easts fans.
Interesting. I wasn't at the elimination final, but all I heard was that the vermin fans outnumbered us. From the footage I saw, both on FOX and Nine, it seemed to be more of us, clearly. I get sick of the media bias and apologists getting behind that filthy mob.
MRR or Rabid
Some people believe supporting the Roosters
is a matter of life and death, I am very disappointed
with that attitude. I can assure you it is
much, much more important than that.
Nooooo…Here Come The Roosters is so much better. Sorry.
I completely agree. I think it is an original song, unlike the vermin who took a great song called the Battle Hymn of the Republic and twisted it. They were not the first to use it either, with the great Tottenham Hotspur football club taking that mantle as far as I know in 1961. The rabble were in 1967.
MRR or Rabid
Some people believe supporting the Roosters
is a matter of life and death, I am very disappointed
with that attitude. I can assure you it is
much, much more important than that.
It is OUR home, OUR ground. Sure, it is owned by the taxpayers, but geographically it is in OUR territory, not theirs. Bondi Junction is closer to Moore Park than Redfern. They have ZERO credibility on this matter.
MRR or Rabid
Some people believe supporting the Roosters
is a matter of life and death, I am very disappointed
with that attitude. I can assure you it is
much, much more important than that.
Comment