Gloating Buzz

[Cockadoodledoo]

LOL& Beating the Bulldogs in 2010 being a fluke That day the team overcame so the most biased and disgraceful refreeing decisios aginst them or any other team that I have witnessed in all my years of watching Rugby League

I felt like we were forced to win that game twice..

[stsae]

It's not what Carney didn't do, it's what he did do. I saw close games last year where we tackled our hearts out only to see Carney miss tackles with woeful 'couldn't give a stuff' turnstyle defence which led directly to tries that handed the game to the other team. In those close games that you say we fluked near the end, I bet if Carney was in the team we would have lost those games too because he would have handed the opposition a try or two with just this type of defence.
I also witnessed his woeful kicking and total lack of interest in being out there. My argument is that if Carney played those last four games, we lose them. So yes, I believe he can be held responsible for most of our woe last year - off -field and on.

This, brilliant, exactly how it went down. Carntey played like a gimp last season. Well put MR.

[Vasco]

I felt like we were forced to win that game twice..

As Warren Ryan said on ABC radio that day:

"Justice was played out on the field today".

[Guest]

bs stats. Take a closer look at those 7 wins. Most of them were flukey late victories against lowly teams who played better than us. Anyone getting excited about those wins is clueless.

Back to the point. There are 13 players on the field. Why single out Carney? How did the players become so dependent on one player? Why weren't they able to perform unless Carney put the game on a platter for them?


You just have to go back to 2007 and 2009 to realise that this team has more serious issues that go beyond any one single player or person at the club. In 2007 how on earth did we go from certain wooden spooners to a premiership threat overnight? and then wooden spooners in 2009? The core of our squad comprises mentally weak and unprofessional players. It has has nothing to do with Carney, Myles, Mason, Finch, Freddy, or whoever else we blame for this year or next year's failures.

The reason I brought up Manly is they are a similar team. It is only the smarts of Hasler in giving unconditional support and camaraderie to the players which has kept them from self-destructing like us. They could have very easily sacked Stewart and it would have been all over for them.

Winning ugly is the sign of a good team not a bad one.

[Guest]

LOL& Beating the Bulldogs in 2010 being a fluke That day the team overcame so the most biased and disgraceful refreeing decisios aginst them or any other team that I have witnessed in all my years of watching Rugby League

For the record, i don't believe there is such a thing as a 'flukey' win.

It was more of a counter-point to dice's insinuations that we are only winning ugly without Carney by luck, when in fact the victories are very much the same to the ones that happened in 2010.

You create your own luck.

[redwhiteblue]

LOL& Beating the Bulldogs in 2010 being a fluke That day the team overcame so the most biased and disgraceful refreeing decisios aginst them or any other team that I have witnessed in all my years of watching Rugby League

I still have that game on VHS and now on the T-box. I remember ringing everyone I knew that day, including interrupting my sister and her family on holiday at the Gold Coast, to sound off about that one.

[Guest]

Hehe 19 pages on Rothfield lol.

[Guest]

Mr. Rothfield is a journalist.

[Guest]

Hehe 19 pages on Rothfield lol.

How good is this thread?

[Guest]

I still have that game on VHS and now on the T-box. I remember ringing everyone I knew that day, including interrupting my sister and her family on holiday at the Gold Coast, to sound off about that one.

VHS????

He was talking about the game in 2010 - not 1910!!!

[Guest]

It just gets better - 20 pages bitches

[Guest]

It just gets better - 20 pages bitches

You did that on purpose.

Chook.

[Guest]

Double page spread in the Telegraph today about Carney.

Big headline quote, "At this club they treat me as a human."

He says that Smith and Anasta caused him to leave. No news there unfortunately.

Of course, Buzz admits he was wrong. What a surprise.

Getting rid of Carney to satisfy the ego of a couple of twits who won't be there in the near future will prove the most idiotic decision we will ever make.

And of course Buzz is gloating.

So would I.

He still can't believe the gift our stupidity has given him.

Maloney is a poor man's Carney and Carney is better than SBW.

We had the diamond in our hands and threw it away.

What a bunch of idiots we are.

BTW ... Todd, you didn't leave mate, you were sent packing.

All the same wish him all the best at the Sharkies

[Guest]

BTW ... Todd, you didn't leave mate, you were sent packing.

No.

He requested a release and it was granted.

Idiots that we are.

[stsae]

No.

He requested a release and it was granted.

Idiots that we are.

So are you saying we should've kept him when he requested a release???

Fark me he played like a gimp last season and requests a release but it's the clubs fault???

And they call me backwards.