Gloating Buzz

[Guest]

"He would still be at the Roosters if it wasn't for..."

Tells you more than whoever wrote the article realises.

I am still not convinced Toddy is happy at Cronulla. I also genuinely believe his 2010 year with us was the best year of league he's had - you could see it in the way he engaged with the crowd.

I think he is starting to realise he will never get that back.

[Rocky Rhodes]

newsflash.

there are not many nice guys who are footy players. there are some but the overwhelming majority would be put in another category in my opinion.

but if it makes people happy to think we have angels in our team currently then so be it.

Exactly. Most of the top players in the game are head cases....

Footballers should be judged on footballing ability alone.

[Guest]

newsflash.

there are not many nice guys who are footy players. there are some but the overwhelming majority would be put in another category in my opinion.

but if it makes people happy to think we have angels in our team currently then so be it.

No there are probably not, but society is much the same. That's hardly the point though, nice or not, the vast proportion of players in our team don't put themselves ahead of the footy team. If they are reprimanded for one reason or another, they try and at least act as if they are repentant. I can hardly say the same for Carney...

[Guest]

But but....we are now nice boys, good wholesome boys and Andrew Ettinghausen types. No chance to win a comp but we don't care because we are nice boys. We can take our wifes to the footy and enjoy our nice boys trying their best, just keep an eye out on ya wifes.

Sure we cleaned out the A-holes however in doing so we cleaned out most of the real talent. But but we are nice boys.....

Totally agree. But what else did you expect from The Playboy Board ? Quite frankly, too many of those educated by the Murdoch propaganda machine have far too big a say in our club. Most are chicks too ... remember the laughable Willie Mason petition ? Get rid of these idiots from your ear Nick. They have no idea about the real world and instead live in total fantasy where everyone is nice and those who rock the boat and disturb their little fantasy are either imprisoned or have their lives totally destroyed.

Thank God Cronulla came to Todd's rescue. He's never deserved the bullshit that gets thrown his way. We had our chance to win a comp and blew it. Enjoy waiting another 20 years because thats how long it'll take to find another talent like Carney. Nice guys finish last.

[Guest]

BUzz must really be upset that he knew nothing about the E.T scoop, what with him having such great inside knowledge on all that is the sharks.

I take what this fark-knuckle says with a grain of salt

[Guest]

Carney will quit Rugby League before the 2012 season is finished. He'll fark up and quit before he gets sacked because he's a selfish, gutless, alchoholic coward.

He'll be playing ESL in 2013, you heard it here first.

Chook.

[stsae]

Spot on Pendulum,

Peeps need to know the truth not the propaganda, Carney (although culpable) was stitched up by Smith & Anasta, the inconsistency in retaining FPN for the same indiscretion, inexcusable...

Foxsports: Carney's own comments,

Quote:

"Carney is blaming no one else for his problems and issues of the past.

But truth be known, he would still be at Sydney Roosters if it wasn't for coach Brian Smith and skipper Braith Anasta.

He fell out with Smith over some derogatory comments that were made after Carney won the Dally M player-of-the-year award.

And it's common knowledge at the Roosters that Anasta disliked playing in the forwards and got upset when Carney took his five-eighth jersey.

Neither supported him when the club was making a decision towards the end of last season on his future at the club.

The Roosters' loss has been a massive gain for the Sharks." unquote

Carnteys own comments???

Where are the actual Carntey quotes??? That bit there is he said stuff. Why hasn't the man himself come out and said what's what instead of hiding behind others???

I'm was a Carntey fan, I don't give a shit what players do off the field as long as they perform on it, which Carntey didn't do last season. He ran dead, he is soft for doing that, no matter what the reason.

This is just another dig at our club and our coach and our current captain.

Some of youse, the coach haters, are using this shit to get milage to fill your agendas. How farking low will you blokes stoop??? Just as soft as Carntey and our management.

And you DarkHole, don't come and compliment the team for a good win, just jump on this bandwagon. You ain't a fan of this club you're a carnt.

Dead set we won on the weekend, finally did what everyone's wanted played well. And we get this shit???

Open your eyes people.

[Headless Chook]

I've read this stuff before.....trying to think when it was....ohhhh that's right March/April 2010.

[Guest]

Spot on Pendulum,

the inconsistency in retaining FPN for the same indiscretion, inexcusable...

unquote

This is factually incorrect

As I have said before on these forums Smithy said at the Fan Forum that the sole reason FPN was given a shot at staying was because he turned up the next day without his manager and said sorry, and took responsibility.

Carney and Sh its in Corridors wouldnt answer phone calls and then got their managers to ring and try and get them out of it and never acknowledged any fault and from this article we can see still dont

[Headless Chook]

It smells to me like Rothfield wanted to do the proposed 'Club in Crisis' article but couldn't because we're actually going okay, so he did the Carney 'I'm not an Animal' article instead. Serves a dual purpose.....writes up his beloved Sharkies and at the same time allows him to take potshots at the Roosters.

[Guest]

and gets idiots like us tal;king about him all day

[mightyrooster]

It smells to me like Rothfield wanted to do the proposed 'Club in Crisis' article but couldn't because we're actually going okay, so he did the Carney 'I'm not an Animal' article instead. Serves a dual purpose.....writes up his beloved Sharkies and at the same time allows him to take potshots at the Roosters.

And apparently he's off sick today - according to their website - so he's not available to answer question in his on line blog today!

[Guest]

Its Carney's honeymoon period. We'll see in 2013 how he will mess his career and life up!

[Jacks Fur Coat]

When will people learn to ignore the Rothfield anti-Easts driven agenda? He will try ANYTHING to upset us especially when he gets nervous after a strong display such as last Saturday.

We did the right thing by punting Todd...unfortunate ending but still the right decision.

Move on now people...nothing to be gained by looking back over this bit of history.

[John Corey]

Double page spread in the Telegraph today about Carney.

Big headline quote, "At this club they treat me as a human."

He says that Smith and Anasta caused him to leave. No news there unfortunately.

Of course, Buzz admits he was wrong. What a surprise.

Getting rid of Carney to satisfy the ego of a couple of twits who won't be there in the near future will prove the most idiotic decision we will ever make.

And of course Buzz is gloating.

So would I.

He still can't believe the gift our stupidity has given him.

Maloney is a poor man's Carney and Carney is better than SBW.

We had the diamond in our hands and threw it away.

What a bunch of idiots we are.

I dont agree with any of your comments. Carney was absolute crap last year. You cant just hang your hat on 2010. The guy has massive problems and he will come unstuck before the end of the year. You want to call our Club stupid for letting him go? I would suggest that our coaches, CEO & Club sponsors probably have more knowledge of the entire situation (and all his indiscretions) than you do.

I honestly dont care if he has a blinder for the Sharks this year. I am glad we punted his ass. He deserved everything he got. We are not a child care centre or social workers.