Toyota Cup Judiciary Charges : Round 5

[fletch]

Evans Kane Roosters 38th minute

Contrary Conduct - Fighting 3

325 points

Early Plea: 243
Guilty: 325

[Guest]

Two games, isn't it?

They will struggle if Moga gets a call up to FG.

[Guest]

They will really struggle without Evans. He is their heart and soul. The only other good forward is Dylan Napa. The whole backrow is close to useless.

[Andrew Walker]

That charge is a disgrace of the highest order Up to 7 Warriors ran in to the unitial fight before Evans came in to help his team mate out He did do some damge though once he arrived I am shocked by this

[Yak]

No charges should have come from that. It was not much more than a scuffle. Can't believe they got the penalty from that when their number 4 just decided he'd start punching Vunipola without warning. Evans had a right to take his head off.

Speaking of Vunipola. He's a player I did not rate one bit last year. He appeared heartless and I wondered why he was getting picked so much. But this year he's shown his worth with a few powerful tries. He'll need to step up massively. Shame they don't have Brandon Tago to rely on if Kane is out for a couple of weeks. He looked ready for a big year after playing in the first grade trial. He may even get brought back early if Evans is suspended. They can't rely on Tai Tauivasa having too much game time, he was pathetic in defence on the line last week. So slow and lazy.

[Guest]

Anyone have a video of it?

[Andrew Walker]

No charges should have come from that. It was not much more than a scuffle. Can't believe they got the penalty from that when their number 4 just decided he'd start punching Vunipola without warning. Evans had a right to take his head off.

Speaking of Vunipola. He's a player I did not rate one bit last year. He appeared heartless and I wondered why he was getting picked so much. But this year he's shown his worth with a few powerful tries. He'll need to step up massively. Shame they don't have Brandon Tago to rely on if Kane is out for a couple of weeks. He looked ready for a big year after playing in the first grade trial. He may even get brought back early if Evans is suspended. They can't rely on Tai Tauivasa having too much game time, he was pathetic in defence on the line last week. So slow and lazy.

Yak siting right near where it happened I can assure you Evans did some major damage to a few of there players My gues is he belted 3 to 4 of them one with about 4 shots to the head However he was only protecting his team mate Who was hit for what looked like no reason and then had about 7 wariors players come join in

I was in disbelief they were awarded the penalty Do you know who 14 for us is Cat of the highest order stood there remonstarting with the ref whilst his team mate had to contend with 7 players instead of getting in and helping him out I hope I never see this cat pklay in our colours again

[Rooster_6]

Titans and Cowboys have shit NYC sides anyway, should still win those games comfortably.

He was probably close to a first grade call up though.

[TheLoneRooster]

... Do you know who 14 for us is Cat of the highest order stood there remonstarting with the ref whilst his team mate had to contend with 7 players instead of getting in and helping him out I hope I never see this cat pklay in our colours again

Mr Walker, I believe number 14 is Dean Blackman, signed from the Eels NYC.

[alex0063]

There is a highlight of the Fight on Foxsports website I cant link the video for some reason.

[Guest]

There is a highlight of the Fight on Foxsports website I cant link the video for some reason.

Yeah I see it now

http://www.foxsports.com.au/League/t...site=FoxSports

[Andrew Walker]

Hmm Might have been a bit harsh on 14 he was in there to stert but slipeed out pretty quickly He is still a cat and should have got back involved