Justin Carney: Winger, Centre, Prop?

[Funky Chicken]

So why not have;

Minichiello
Tagive
Carney
SKD
Perrett

[bondi-boy]

Justin Carney is a centre.
He doesn't really have much idea how to be a winger.

[stephenj]

i keep looking for reasons to drop him, but he keeps coming up with reasons to retain him!

[Guest]

He played well tonight

[SConcierge]

So why not have;

Minichiello
Tagive
Carney
SKD
Perrett

BJ and SKD have to be our centres, BJ is a handful and a powerful runner and hits hard in defence. He is only 20 with 50 games under his belt he will start to come good next year with experience.

[Arties Pie]

BJ and SKD have to be our centres, BJ is a handful and a powerful runner and hits hard in defence. He is only 20 with 50 games under his belt he will start to come good next year with experience.

But BJ still has far too many mistakes in him.

[BUDDY]

BJ and SKD have to be our centres, BJ is a handful and a powerful runner and hits hard in defence. He is only 20 with 50 games under his belt he will start to come good next year with experience.

Apparently as a Tigpie.

[SConcierge]

But BJ still has far too many mistakes in him.

Mate he is only 20?? and only played 47 games! I hope that Tigers thing is a crap. We cant afford to loose 50 game players that we have been developing like BJ and Linnett.

[Geohood]

Carney had a good game IMO tonight. One of these days he's gonna score an individual long range try he has it in him! Has poked his nose through a few times.

[Guest]

Has poked his nose through a few times.

Him poking his nose through is like when you are in a rush to make the toilet.

His new nick should be "Touching Cloth".

[Arties Pie]

Mate he is only 20?? and only played 47 games! I hope that Tigers thing is a crap. We cant afford to loose 50 game players that we have been developing like BJ and Linnett.

This is 1st's not reggies, if he's not good enough then he shouldn't be there.

[Headless Chook]

Carney had a good game IMO tonight. One of these days he's gonna score an individual long range try he has it in him! Has poked his nose through a few times.

I agree, he's improving each game. I think that badly broken leg really damaged his confidence and its only just starting to return.

[Guest]

He is starting to find his feet in attack and defence. Probably needs some early ball and not just used as a battering ram every time!

[stsae]

He is starting to find his feet in attack and defence. Probably needs some early ball and not just used as a battering ram every time!

It would be nice if he got A ball in some space, sadly the bloke usually inside him, Bwaiff is shit. I won't hammer BJ too much. He is a baby, has to receive the same shit ball from Bwaiff and plays a lot of wing swapping with Carntey.

Our left side starts and ends with Bwaiffs shitness.

I'd love to see Mortein given the role of controlling that side of the field. Certainly Bwaiff deserves demotion, on his form alone.

I feel we will have to wait till next season to see what Baloney can do with that side of the field.

[Guest]

Bj needs to be in the backrow. He has alot of skills and strength and it would be a shame to see him go. As fir carney he is going pretty well