Chooks in a flap over Todd

[Arties Pie]

Oh come on!!! Thurston here? Yeah right as if he ever was going to come. He's happy with his pips in NQ. He would never had lasted in Bondi and if anything, the Broncos would have gotten him, had he wanted a big club.

I think from memory that it was Stuart that didn't want him.

[Guest]

I don't believe gallen wanted to ever come to the roosters or even ever leave cronulla......dream on buddy

Enjoy your ignorance "buddy".

[stsae]

Robson is their Mitchell Pearce. Only he gets repeat sets.

Shame Pearce has to be our Carntey and Robson cos our captains a steamer.

In fact they also have a 1 and 9 who contribute to the attack in a much more positive way than ours have since Pearce debuted.

But yeah he does struggle with the repeat set thingy IMO.

I'm renaming Pearce, Pat Malone.

[Headless Chook]

He was instrumental in the try that sealed the game.
We chose Anasta over him.

That was as dumb as when we chose Finch over Thurston.

Instrumental??? Hahaha....he nearly got caught on the last tackle and threw a hail mary out the back to Robson who put a lovely little kick through for Graham. If Carney was instrumental, I'm interested in hearing how you describe Robson's role in the try.....

[Guest]

Instrumental??? Hahaha....he nearly got caught on the last tackle and threw a hail mary out the back to Robson who put a lovely little kick through for Graham. If Carney was instrumental, I'm interested in hearing how you describe Robson's role in the try.....

That wasn't a hail mary. He passed it where he wanted to to keep the ball alive.

Robson was also instrumental.

How about you instead compare his performance with that of our five-eight? That is more relevant.

[Guest]

Carney has already made a big difference to the sharks, and he's not even at his best yet.

[stsae]

All I know is what I know.

And that was at the end of last season.
As I said, our dealings were at the start of last season. Before the contract they refer to that was then extended.

He was here and we blew it. Now we get to see him be the most dominant forward in the comp for someone else.

Lol, bullshit, PlumbBob.

You JusT know what your told, what others want you to know and/or what you want us to believe, where your opinion swings this week.

I know you're as passionate as any of us but sometimes "being in the know" is really misleading mate.

That said I'm not denying you on this or anything you feed us, cos i dont know or claim to, I'm just hoping the sheep will put it into perspective.

So how bout something important to us NOW as fans. Whats the deal with JWH??? Is it gonna happen or not??? If so when will us plebs know about it???

No offense PlumbBob, don't pull that old Cry Baby Cry on my arse ok mate. BTW I love that song, so apt to this forum.

[Guest]

LOL@the people saying Carney is a superstar and a big game player.

[stsae]

Carney has already made a big difference to the sharks, and he's not even at his best yet.

Bullshit Fredo, mate you will be telling us next you knew this was gonna happen 7 yrs ago.

Seriously you don't even support the Coqq, you just wait for the team to lose a few and bag the coach, you've been at it since pRicky was in charge.

[Guest]

On JWH, I know we want to keep him.

But hey, that's just what I've been told.

Unlike the Gallen thing. That was much more hands on.

[Guest]

So does that mean we can add gallen to the long list of players that smith didn't rate who turned out to be superstars eg Mateo, tonga, hayne etc.

[Guest]

So does that mean we can add gallen to the long list of players that smith didn't rate who turned out to be superstars eg Mateo, tonga, hayne etc.

Lock him in.

[stsae]

On JWH, I know we want to keep him.

But hey, that's just what I've been told.

That at least I can live with.

Basically it means if we lose him it's not from lack of wanting him, which IMO would be foolish.

And I'm heartened by it as we all know we rarely lose those we really WANT to keep.

Thank you PlumbBob for your answering my questions. I know I'm JusT a pain at times, but I do really love you long time baby. You too Fredo.

[Guest]

it's not that simple. It was the cancerous effect carney was having on the whole club in 2011.

bingo!

[Guest]

I admit i've only read the title of this thread,but what's al this about chook flaps & Todd??..