Chooks in a flap over Todd

[bondi-boy]

He was instrumental in the try that sealed the game.

We chose Anasta over him.

That was as dumb as when we chose Finch over Thurston.

We really had no choice but to choose Anasta over him.
Sponsors, image, money/cap, former Easts greats...etc.

Times have changed...'bad boys' are out of fashion these days.
And 'good boys' rule!

[bondi-boy]

Carney has indeed already made a big difference to the sharks.

...just as he did to our team in 2010.

[Guest]

The love child is in the house!!! ^^^^^^^^^^^^^

[Guest]

Didn't read thread but Carney said on twitter he was misquoted and still loves our club.

[bondi-boy]

The love child is in the house!!! ^^^^^^^^^^^^^

It is true ... he has made a big difference to the Sharks in attack, just as he did to our team in 2010, you know it is true.

[Guest]

It is true ... he has made a big difference to the Sharks in attack, just as he did to our team in 2010, you know it is true.

Working with your theory, by this time next year then, he will be a drunk waste of the cap, destabilizing their team and looking for a new home by the end of the season.

I like it!

[stsae]

Working with your theory, by this time next year then, he will be a drunk waste of the cap, destabilizing their team and looking for a new home by the end of the season.

I like it!

Especially if they make the GF this season, lose, and he is exposed again on the big stage.

That would make the Tardpoles 46yr old virgins.

[John Corey]

I used to live and work in the Shire and loved watching the Sharks get beat. But I have nothing but admiration for the football they are playing this year. They are a bloody tough football side and Gallen must be close to the best player in the com, or at least the most valuable.

I am happy for Carney but still glad we pissed him off.

[Guest]

Carney has already made a big difference to the sharks, and he's not even at his best yet.

They may not yet have seen him at his best but I'll bet my house they are also yet to see him at his worst.

[Headless Chook]

That wasn't a hail mary. He passed it where he wanted to to keep the ball alive.

Robson was also instrumental.

How about you instead compare his performance with that of our five-eight? That is more relevant.

Why is it more relevant? I never compared him to our 5/8th at anytime, you're the one who has now dragged Anasta into it to try and justify your manlove for Carney. I merely commented that his kicking game was good but he was average in general play. You then tried to tell me he set up the match winning try, when all he did was toss the ball to Robson because he made a poor decision to try and run it on the last tackle.

[Guest]

Neither has 'anyone' else much.

That's where JWH will be playing...[Yikes! South Africa, wouldn't catch me ever setting foot in that place].........not infrequently if he signs with the Waratahs.
He won't be the star he is in the NRL.

I went to South africa for a holiday and it was awesome.. great people great food and wine and obvioulsy the wild life. I was a bit iffy to go but got a free trip... cant wait to go back...Im a sucker for a wild life doco though so was in awe.

The Saffas there are better than a lot of the ones here!

[Guest]

Why is it more relevant? I never compared him to our 5/8th at anytime, you're the one who has now dragged Anasta into it to try and justify your manlove for Carney. I merely commented that his kicking game was good but he was average in general play. You then tried to tell me he set up the match winning try, when all he did was toss the ball to Robson because he made a poor decision to try and run it on the last tackle.

It's relevant to me because anything to do with Carney has to be compared to Braith. As far as I am concerned he should still be out 5/8.

[novice chook]

Fark me why are supporters still pining over the drunkard bogan. He's gone and it's a bloody good thing given the disharmony he was causing within the club.

Get over the fact he's gone and move on. He won't be coming back. And that's a good thing.

As others have said, Robson is playing as well or better than Carney and that's one of the main reasons Cronulla have suddenly improved since he came into the side. But because he's not flashy and uninteresting he gets very little of the credit or attention.

The media are taking great delight in building the drunkard bogan up again, secure in the knowledge that sooner or later he'll fall from grace yet gain and sell them copious amounts of papers as they rejoice in his demise.

NC

[Guest]

I agree with ^^^^^^

[Guest]

I went to South africa for a holiday and it was awesome.. great people great food and wine and obvioulsy the wild life. I was a bit iffy to go but got a free trip... cant wait to go back...Im a sucker for a wild life doco though so was in awe.

The Saffas there are better than a lot of the ones here!

You obviously didn't go to my home suburb Hillbrow. Did you go to Cape Town ?