Radley Charged

[King Salvo]

Look I'm not defending Rads here. Personally I think that a penalty/fine would've been sufficient. It was fractionally late and wasn't high. A sin bin was harsh, especially considering that Cody Wanker wasnt binned when he ran halfway across the field to push Sammy over the other week.

And be honest.... if given the chance who on here wouldn't want to push Munster over. Heck I would've pushed him twice as hard

Problem was that he wasn't even attempting a tackle so that would pique the interest of the beady eye folk in the NRL Bunker in Eveleigh.

[Rooster1908]

Yeah but.... Murray plays for the vermin. Rads plays for us. Its apples and oranges

Would you swap Rads for Murray .

[Rooster_6]

Would you swap Rads for Murray .

For good and bad Radley is ours.

Wouldn't swap him for vermin.

Go wash your mouth out.

[ism22]

Yeah but.... Murray plays for the vermin. Rads plays for us. Its apples and oranges

I think that's my only real frustration here.

It was a stupid, unnecessary thing to do. Personally I've got no issue with sin-binning a guy who blocks an almost certain try by taking somebody out. FINE!

What I don't like is that...

- It seems to be the HARSHEST possible punishment. Don't just sin-bin him and ruin our game (which is more than just punishment IMO)... suspend him too while you're at it!

- Other shyte that's far worse gets missed. Thus while it's good to look at this sorta thing in isolation, I am bitter that other players can do worse and get nothing.

- Sigh. Guess it will always be like this if I compare though.

[Rooster1908]

For good and bad Radley is ours.

Wouldn't swap him for vermin.

Go wash your mouth out.

What if we could win a comp with Murray but Not Rads
Love Rads to but Murray if you want to be honest has the wood all over him

[rooster till i die]

Victor been binned 6 times last 3 years,twice v broncos, twice v souths last year semi,last night and all 3 games we list,6th bin I haven't details...these could make difference between making 8 or top 4...he's a liability.

Agree totally. Victor is a liability!

[Rooster_6]

What if we could win a comp with Murray but Not Rads
Love Rads to but Murray if you want to be honest has the wood all over him

I remember when it was a popular opinion on here that Boyd Cordner didn't have the attitude to make it as a player at this club. Or that Jake Friend didn't have the talent and how we needed a hooker like x, y or z.

Now all I think about every time I watch us play is how we haven't had leadership like them since.

Radley still has time, he only just hit 100 games. Don't worry about how green the neighbours grass is right now, Radley is our guy, he's a local junior and he's got too much talent and heart not to come good.

[Sentimentinel]

I remember when it was a popular opinion on here that Boyd Cordner didn't have the attitude to make it as a player at this club. Or that Jake Friend didn't have the talent and how we needed a hooker like x, y or z.

Now all I think about every time I watch us play is how we haven't had leadership like them since.

Radley still has time, he only just hit 100 games. Don't worry about how green the neighbours grass is right now, Radley is our guy, he's a local junior and he's got too much talent and heart not to come good.

He's already delivered 2 premierships as well. Murray=ZERO

Even though they both play lock, Rads has more to his game overall, playmaking especially.

The infatuation with the Storm team and souffs players on here sometimes makes me wonder if I've stumbled onto the wrong forum.

[bondi.boy]

Yeah he copped a fine also.

was Walker sin binned too?

[bondi.boy]

Radley sin binned...Roosters lose game.

Dogs player sin binned...Dogs lose game.
2 Cowboys sin binned...Cows lose game.

All our player purchases...all that money spent...
All our team's sweat and effort training...
and Radley just blew it all away with his stupid play.
Murray played well, scored a good try for Souths, no sin bin, Souths won.

[BillyBonkers]

What if we could win a comp with Murray but Not Rads
Love Rads to but Murray if you want to be honest has the wood all over him

Vacuous Victor the Vacant or Murray hmmmmm

Bugger it Murray easily.

[Jacks Fur Coat]

For good and bad Radley is ours.

Wouldn't swap him for vermin.

Go wash your mouth out.

Eloquently put!

Mostly good thankfully.

No way I'd swap him for girlface.

[Rooster1908]

He's already delivered 2 premierships as well. Murray=ZERO

Even though they both play lock, Rads has more to his game overall, playmaking especially.

The infatuation with the Storm team and souffs players on here sometimes makes me wonder if I've stumbled onto the wrong forum.

You mistake infatuation with admiration for players or teams that continue to have success without looking to past glories to justify mediocrity.
Love and followed the Roosters for 50 odd years and will continue to do so but some on here even believe Thursdays game was acceptable and continue to make all sorts of excuses.

[The Monk]

for a fairy tap that had no impact on anything.

[BillyBonkers]

What success has Cameron Murray had?

Do you equate ability to premierships ?

How many premierships did Kevin Hastings be a part of?