Radley Charged

[BillyBonkers]

for a fairy tap that had no impact on anything.

We are talking Victor the Vacant.

[Sentimentinel]

Do you equate ability to premierships ?

How many premierships did Kevin Hastings be a part of?

No premierships crush "ability"

[SupermanSupportsEasts4Eva]

Would you swap Rads for Murray .

I respect Murray as a player, but would prefer to keep Rads. I know others may have a different opinion but loyalty of players to their club is something that I hold in high regard

[Sentimentinel]

You mistake infatuation with admiration for players or teams that continue to have success without looking to past glories to justify mediocrity.
Love and followed the Roosters for 50 odd years and will continue to do so but some on here even believe Thursdays game was acceptable and continue to make all sorts of excuses.

You can admire a souffs player that's won nothing. Fine by me lol

[SupermanSupportsEasts4Eva]

I think that's my only real frustration here.

It was a stupid, unnecessary thing to do. Personally I've got no issue with sin-binning a guy who blocks an almost certain try by taking somebody out. FINE!

What I don't like is that...

- It seems to be the HARSHEST possible punishment. Don't just sin-bin him and ruin our game (which is more than just punishment IMO)... suspend him too while you're at it!

- Other shyte that's far worse gets missed. Thus while it's good to look at this sorta thing in isolation, I am bitter that other players can do worse and get nothing.

- Sigh. Guess it will always be like this if I compare though.

Yep spot on. If it was Murray that had pushed Munster over no one would've had a second look. The commentary and tv replays would've zoomed in on the amazing work of the defensive winger who saved a try

[Batemans Bay Rooster]

Brown due back round 7 . Though him straight in for Rads . Cant be any worse

FFS what nonsense

[milanja]

We have enough ex Souths players/juniors in our squad at the moment( nine I think, if not more) no need to take another.

vic is ours, not many in the game play with the same passion, he just has to get a run of games where he stays on the field more.

Hopefully his good, out does his bad soon though.

[zac]

presumably people have mentioned james graham's comments and he has a point. still, relieved that we've got rads this week.
soccer gives yellow cards for people who fake a dive in the penalty box. maybe league should look at something similar. munster didn't fake being hit late, but he made a meal of it

[Rooster1908]

FFS what nonsense

Why ????

[Water boy]

Radley was up there as one of the best locks in the game. Under supercoach he is now behind Murray, yeo, Carrigan, JT. I'd even say on form he is behind Jack Bird and the ranga from canberra. Unlike Bellamy or Bennette, Has Robbo ever taken an average player and turned him into a star? Imagine the train wreck if Nick Meaney was at the roosters, or Reimis Smith, or Brenko Lee. Under Benny or Belly they exceed potential. Robbo needs a team of international superstars to be competitive.

[milanja]

Why ????

Hasn’t played in quite a while, lesser skills all round, and also a noted hot head, he does offer a hard running style and could see him replacing(if anyone at the moment)Egan, but not Radley.

[milanja]

Radley was up there as one of the best locks in the game. Under supercoach he is now behind Murray, yeo, Carrigan, JT. I'd even say on form he is behind Jack Bird and the ranga from canberra. Unlike Bellamy or Bennette, Has Robbo ever taken an average player and turned him into a star? Imagine the train wreck if Nick Meaney was at the roosters, or Reimis Smith, or Brenko Lee. Under Benny or Belly they exceed potential. Robbo needs a team of international superstars to be competitive.

I think he has turned Toops, fergo,Latrell, Manu, Boyd, friend, JWH, Collins into stars/rep players. He has done well with rejects from other clubs like keary and the Morris bros too.

brenko Lee? Star??

[Rooster1908]

presumably people have mentioned james graham's comments and he has a point. still, relieved that we've got rads this week.
soccer gives yellow cards for people who fake a dive in the penalty box. maybe league should look at something similar. munster didn't fake being hit late, but he made a meal of it

Isn't the point that what RAF's did regardless of if we deem to be nothing , wasn't it illegal . Didn't Rads doing what he did cause him to be be binned and then didn't that contribute heavily to us loosing that game .As such doesn't that mean that it was a stupid act .Love Rads , he is a Rooster Junior , but he has to get the stupid shite out of his game if he is to reach the potential we all see and saw in the bloke a few years back .

[HunchoRooster]

I'm the first one to say Rads has been a massive disappointment the last couple of seasons and he is known for complete brain snaps that are stupid and cost the team on a regular basis... but I think this one was soft and extremely harsh to get a sin bin.

[Water boy]

I think he has turned Toops, fergo,Latrell, Manu, Boyd, friend, JWH, Collins into stars/rep players. He has done well with rejects from other clubs like keary and the Morris bros too.

brenko Lee? Star??

You named guys that wouldve been as great had they gone to tigers. Toups would be the only one Id say you may have an argument. BMoz is considered the greatest winger of all time, I doubt thats due to his 2 seasons under Robbo. My point on Brenko is that he was a fringe first grader just like Hutch, unlike hutch, he is killing it at centre and playing beyond his natural abilities, where as Hutch....well other than robbo, anyone with eyes can see how much of a dud he is. Sam walker at storm would be the australian halfback, sualii at souths would be in the top 3 players. I hope walker goes to dolphins and fulfills his potential.