Player ratings

[Chook2]

Well the only positive was the W
to be up 20 to 6 and 26 to 12 and loose in tries 5 to 4 this was embarrassing
simple mistakes and penalaties down the dragons line and our left edge defence leaked tries a first grade unit should not
also with the radley sin bin that was total bullshit - a head clash this will make people stop Following the game
only thing we found out is sualli can kick
and amazing what competing can do for spots. Egan butcher best game of year with Nat coming back next week and gus and stilili back
and jack bird is surprisingly stronger then he looks

ratings
teddy - 8 - best game this season, still seems out of sink at times, did not realise he had not scored yet
paulo - 7
momo - 5 - seriously this bloke offers nothing, cannot defend or catch a high ball
sualli - 5 - had the try been allowed this would be okay however got done from suli on the outside and crept in leaking tries - needs to go back to wing next week
manu -7 - still not a half but kept busy - with Tupou out next week need manu back at centre and sualli sing asap
keary - 8 - apart from leaking defence one of better games
Jared - 7
smith 8 - best game so far
linday - 8
gus - 5 - good to have him back will get better each game but leaked penalties and dropped balls
Egan - 9 - MOM - best game yet amazing what completion for spots does
radley - 8 - minus sin bin which should have never been his best game this season scoring and setting up tries
. Will let him off this sin bin as it was not one
hutch 5
sitili 6 good to be back
lodge 7
whyte - 7

next week Nat will be back taking Whyte position, gus and Sitili needs a few weeks to be back to best
Egan killed it and earns another start next week
manu needs to move back to centre as no second kicker - and with Tupou out for a coupe of weeks we need him back there to move sualli to the wing, momo May get 1 or 2 more weeks because of Tupou injury

[The Monk]

Piss off both Butchers. One game doesnt make a legend. Your ratings are over ratings.

[Rooster90]

I'd like Junior Pauga to get a run, straight swap for Toops

Kills it every week for the Bears

[Big Dog]

Hutch - 1
Momo - minus 1
Smith - minus 3

[Rooster_6]

I'd like Junior Pauga to get a run, straight swap for Toops

Kills it every week for the Bears

Yeh will be interesting to see what the call is, Robbo said he has to make his decision by tomorrow. Didn’t rule out bringing Walker back and moving Manu back to the centres.

[King Salvo]

3 2 and 1's

3. E Butcher
2. Manu
1. B Smith

The Hutchinator just misses out

[King Salvo]

Yeh will be interesting to see what the call is, Robbo said he has to make his decision by tomorrow. Didn’t rule out bringing Walker back and moving Manu back to the centres.

The Roosters NSW Cup play the Warriors prior to NRL on Sunday

[Rooster_6]

Well the only positive was the W
to be up 20 to 6 and 26 to 12 and loose in tries 5 to 4 this was embarrassing
simple mistakes and penalaties down the dragons line and our left edge defence leaked tries a first grade unit should not
also with the radley sin bin that was total bullshit - a head clash this will make people stop Following the game
only thing we found out is sualli can kick
and amazing what competing can do for spots. Egan butcher best game of year with Nat coming back next week and gus and stilili back
and jack bird is surprisingly stronger then he looks

ratings
teddy - 8 - best game this season, still seems out of sink at times, did not realise he had not scored yet
paulo - 7
momo - 5 - seriously this bloke offers nothing, cannot defend or catch a high ball
sualli - 5 - had the try been allowed this would be okay however got done from suli on the outside and crept in leaking tries - needs to go back to wing next week
manu -7 - still not a half but kept busy - with Tupou out next week need manu back at centre and sualli sing asap
keary - 8 - apart from leaking defence one of better games
Jared - 7
smith 8 - best game so far
linday - 8
gus - 5 - good to have him back will get better each game but leaked penalties and dropped balls
Egan - 9 - MOM - best game yet amazing what completion for spots does
radley - 8 - minus sin bin which should have never been his best game this season scoring and setting up tries
. Will let him off this sin bin as it was not one
hutch 5
sitili 6 good to be back
lodge 7
whyte - 7

next week Nat will be back taking Whyte position, gus and Sitili needs a few weeks to be back to best
Egan killed it and earns another start next week
manu needs to move back to centre as no second kicker - and with Tupou out for a coupe of weeks we need him back there to move sualli to the wing, momo May get 1 or 2 more weeks because of Tupou injury

Very generous on Suaalii, he was at direct fault for 2 of the tries and played a part in 2 others.

Also think Manu had a very mixed bag, 7 is very generous.

[Rooster36]

Hutch - 1
Momo - minus 1
Smith - minus 3

hahahaha unlucky today dog

[Rooster_6]

3 2 and 1's

3. E Butcher
2. Manu
1. B Smith

The Hutchinator just misses out

Manu, really?

He looked very lost out there, had some nice runs but overall struggled to link to his edges and ran plays into a lot of dead ends.

[Steggles]

Manu, really?

He looked very lost out there, had some nice runs but overall struggled to link to his edges and ran plays into a lot of dead ends.

Agree, Manu looked lost.
3. Butcher
2. Collins
1. Smith

On that performance, Egan should push Nat back to the bench for next week.

[Batemans Bay Rooster]

Whyte has something seriously good about him...

[Jacks Fur Coat]

Whyte has something seriously good about him...

He's got that swagger about him that top athletes do. Theres a very good player in there just needs the right coaching and focus.

[Big Dog]

Agree, Manu looked lost.
3. Butcher
2. Collins
1. Smith

On that performance, Egan should push Nat back to the bench for next week.

Keary was the standout for me. Grace under pressure.

[Intercept]

Lodge noticeably better this week than last. Still a bit tentative compared with the back end of last season, but a good sign to see the head gear gone in the second half. One or two more weeks and he'll be back to his best.