Robbo v Hook

[Rooster1908]

Like the Fonze I am never w....

It's not Communist China/North Korea or any other Authoritarian and Totalitarian country such as Russia so we are allowed to have different opinions including being able to critique and counter these and don't have to be sheep/herd like and follow such "opinions" blindly without question

If you want to be a sheep then go ahead and be one but don't complain when you too get shawn though

I couldn't give a XXXX what anonymous folk on an anonymous site think of me at all but obviously seeking such acceptance is important for you - That Kevin "Bloodly" Wilson song comes to mind

Would you or have you ever invited anyone from this site to your house though?

Haven't but there are a few on here that would be welcome based on there show of respect . Obviously that leaves you out. .

[Water boy]

Hook has the last laugh, he doesn’t have to sot through indigenous round.

[NorfolkStreetKid]

Jesus Norfolk you put a lot of time into compiling and comparing all those stats, to try and make the idiotic point that you're somehow trying to make.

Actually it didn't take long to see those stats, they are all from this year.
And the point i am making is that Trent is lucky to be in a position slightly better than a coach who just got sacked for non performance.
I thought it was quite simple to see that.

[King Salvo]

Hook has the last laugh, he doesn’t have to sot through indigenous round.

I am sure that you will make up for it

[Steggles]

Hook has the last laugh, he doesn’t have to sot through indigenous round.

He’s also laughing because he’s had payouts from 3 clubs now. A nice retirement package for Hook; he can spend the rest of his days fishing if he wants.

[Steakface]

Actually MEATHEAD, all I posted in this thread are FACTS.
we are going a lot worse than a simple 5 and 5 scenario.
I've supported the chooks all my life, and I always will.
Doesn't stop me from seeing that they are underperforming,
and for me the coach has been a major factor in that.
I think he has underachieved for the past couple of seasons.
Previously there have been excuses, but this season it comes down to him making very questionable decisions on dropping players, moving them to different positions and persisting with others who consistantly do not produce.
he ain't no guru.
Our next two games are Dragons and Dogs, with a bye thrown in, so we should be 7 wins and 5 losses, if he wakes up to himself and gets the team back on track by reversing some of the decisions he has made then MAYBE we can make the 8.
If he persists with his current agenda we have no chance.
All we need then is for a couple of injuries and it's goodnight from us.

You are free to say we are underperforming. You've even free to criticise.

But your very specific implication in your original post is that Robbo is worse than Hook, and that is because Hook has a better record over the opening rounds this year, and therefore Robbo should also be sacked. YOu even titled your thread 'Hook v Robbo'! LOFL.

I think he has underachieved for the past couple of seasons.

Mate, go back and look at the injury toll in 2021 and how deep we made it.
Then give yourself an uppercut.

We've been quite poor since the tail end of last year.
But we are no where near the stage of needing to boot our 3x prem winning coach who bleeds red white and blue.
That idea is nothing but a knee jerk, short sighted, ill thought through suggestion (to be polite).

Get with the program. Knee Jerk emotional zero patience reactions like 'sack Robbo' under the current circumstances is the kind of shit Tigers and Dogs fans/clubs do. And thats why they are perpetually shit.

[Rooster_6]

I took 100% of Trents results THIS year.
I Love the Roosters, that's why I hate what this GURU is doing with them.
We are LUCKY to be 5 and 5,
We fluked that win against Souths,
and all St george needed was one goal to beat us, they scored 5 tries to our 4.
Robinson's coaching results have been improved by the quality of rosters he has had.

You made judgement calls on their ability to coach exclusively based on this years results, I extrapolated that to provide some greater context.

As for Robinson’s coaching results being improved by the quality of his roster, no shit. But that is true of every coach.

There’s a reason why Bennett had a 63% win rate at the Broncos and a 45% win rate at the Knights. Why Craig Bellamy had a 69% win rate at Melbourne and a 22% win rate for NSW. Why Ivan Cleary went from a 41% win rate at the Tigers to a 61% win rate at the Panthers.

Every coaches results are linked to the quality of their rosters!

[NorfolkStreetKid]

You are free to say we are underperforming. You've even free to criticise.

But your very specific implication in your original post is that Robbo is worse than Hook, and that is because Hook has a better record over the opening rounds this year, and therefore Robbo should also be sacked. YOu even titled your thread 'Hook v Robbo'! LOFL.



Mate, go back and look at the injury toll in 2021 and how deep we made it.
Then give yourself an uppercut.

We've been quite poor since the tail end of last year.
But we are no where near the stage of needing to boot our 3x prem winning coach who bleeds red white and blue.
That idea is nothing but a knee jerk, short sighted, ill thought through suggestion (to be polite).

Get with the program. Knee Jerk emotional zero patience reactions like 'sack Robbo' under the current circumstances is the kind of shit Tigers and Dogs fans/clubs do. And thats why they are perpetually shit.

I think you are having a massive over reaction to my thread, Robbo v Hook, it means Robbo compared to Hook, and it shows that with a bit of luck Hook could have had much better results than Robbo this year, yet he got sacked, and Robbo is still considered a GREAT coach by many on here.
I didn't say Hook is better than Robbo, or that Robbo should be sacked...... that's all in your mind.

[NorfolkStreetKid]

You made judgement calls on their ability to coach exclusively based on this years results, I extrapolated that to provide some greater context.

As for Robinson’s coaching results being improved by the quality of his roster, no shit. But that is true of every coach.

There’s a reason why Bennett had a 63% win rate at the Broncos and a 45% win rate at the Knights. Why Craig Bellamy had a 69% win rate at Melbourne and a 22% win rate for NSW. Why Ivan Cleary went from a 41% win rate at the Tigers to a 61% win rate at the Panthers.

Every coaches results are linked to the quality of their rosters!

I think you are having a massive over reaction to my thread, Robbo v Hook, it means Robbo compared to Hook, and it shows that with a bit of luck Hook could have had much better results than Robbo this year, yet he got sacked, and Robbo is still considered a GREAT coach by many on here.
I didn't say Hook is better than Robbo, or that Robbo should be sacked...... that's all in your mind

[mightyrooster]

I think you are having a massive over reaction to my thread, Robbo v Hook, it means Robbo compared to Hook, and it shows that with a bit of luck Hook could have had much better results than Robbo this year, yet he got sacked, and Robbo is still considered a GREAT coach by many on here.
I didn't say Hook is better than Robbo, or that Robbo should be sacked...... that's all in your mind.

Hook wasn’t sacked on results from this year alone though. He was sacked for several years of complete failure.

[The Lip]

St George just sacked their coach.
They have won 2 from 10, bad right ?
We have won 5 from 10.
It could so easily be very different.
We are 10th and they are 16th.
They lost 3 games by 2 points, and one by one point.
We won one game by 2 points and one by one point.
They have scored 51 more points than us this season.
They have a 18 point better for and against than us.
They scored more tries than us when they lost to us on Anzac Day.
In the last 2 weeks we are down 68 to 10, they are 60 to 36.
If we had lost those two close games, and they had won their 4 close ones, they would be on 6 wins, and we would be on 3.
They would be 8th and we would be 16th.
But their coach is shiit right, and ours is a guru.

If my Aunty had balls she'd be screwing your wife

[Jacks Fur Coat]

If my Aunty had balls she'd be screwing your wife

Pearce off with shit like that. Only on social media..

[The Lip]

Pearce off with shit like that. Only on social media..

Just an attempt at humour Jack - no harm intended - I'll keep trying

Clearly my Auntie can't have balls so from that point on I think we know it's in jest - hang on these days I'm not so sure my Aunty can at least identify as one with balls