Linnett,Towers & Tuigamala

[Guest]

Williamson is a right side player and Linnett is a left side player. It will depend on who goes to fullback, if Mini goes to 1 Williamson will play if Perret goes to 1 Linnett will play. Neither will play in the centers they will play wing.

[Guest]

When Graham was out injured, Jones came into the centres

Please dont remind me, I am still having nightmares about him trying to tackle idris.

[Cockadoodledoo]

Never agreed with it. Just saying he has been named as 18th man, and last time we had an injury in the outside backs, he was brought in as the replacement

I think based on the results we can conclude it will not happen again.

[Guest]

Williamson is a right side player and Linnett is a left side player. It will depend on who goes to fullback, if Mini goes to 1 Williamson will play if Perret goes to 1 Linnett will play. Neither will play in the centers they will play wing.

What happened to Willo last weekend going by his stats he had a very quiet game?

http://live.nrlstats.com/matches/nrl/match3195.html

[Cockadoodledoo]

So Carney is no hope?

Fark.

Not at all.. but the word is he is less than a 50% chance of playing. Apparently there is a reasonable chance of the injury worsening if he plays.. I don't think it is worth risking that in a game you are less likely to win anyway.

[Guest]

What happened to Willo last weekend going by his stats he had a very quiet game?

http://live.nrlstats.com/matches/nrl/match3195.html

I thought the same thing and i haven't spoken to him this week to find out. Jake Friend was talking to his dad and said Ryan played really well especially in defence, but had very limited opportunity with the ball.

[redwhiteandbluester]

Not at all.. but the word is he is less than a 50% chance of playing. Apparently there is a reasonable chance of the injury worsening if he plays.. I don't think it is worth risking that in a game you are less likely to win anyway.

Hate to be a pessimist but if Carney's out, I don't think the Chooks will have enough points in them against such a strong defence.

They wouldn't send him out if he's underdone but for such a big match I think they would be more likely to have a punt than not.

[Guest]

With Jones at 18th man, you would assume he would come into the side should Carney be ruled out

1. Minichello
2. Graham
3. Jones
4. SKD
5. Perret

I hope not.

[Guest]

Hate to be a pessimist but if Carney's out, I don't think the Chooks will have enough points in them against such a strong defence.

They wouldn't send him out if he's underdone but for such a big match I think they would be more likely to have a punt than not.

If Carney is out the only way we'll win is if Saints take us lightly.

[fletch]

it would be stupid to risk a half fit Carney this early in the season, even with him in the side we would be at long odds to trouble the Dragons this Sunday we are still a long way off their standard.

there is nothing wrong with blooding one of the youngsters this weekend, its a great opportunity to see if they can handle the step up to first grade

[novice chook]

I thought the same thing and i haven't spoken to him this week to find out. Jake Friend was talking to his dad and said Ryan played really well especially in defence, but had very limited opportunity with the ball.

Watching the game, he didn't exactly go looking for it either. A little more effort on his part to get involved wouldn't hurt.


NC

[melon....]

it would be stupid to risk a half fit Carney this early in the season, even with him in the side we would be at long odds to trouble the Dragons this Sunday we are still a long way off their standard.

there is nothing wrong with blooding one of the youngsters this weekend, its a great opportunity to see if they can handle the step up to first grade

Blood them against the cows. the dragons will put 60 on us. its not a game to blood anyone.

[Guest]

it would be stupid to risk a half fit Carney this early in the season, even with him in the side we would be at long odds to trouble the Dragons this Sunday we are still a long way off their standard.

there is nothing wrong with blooding one of the youngsters this weekend, its a great opportunity to see if they can handle the step up to first grade

I disagree. At our best we could easily beat them. I believe we have more skill than they do. If we can improve our defence then there is no reason why we can't beat them.

[Geohood]

Does anyone have any official news on Carney's chances to play??

[melon....]

Does anyone have any official news on Carney's chances to play??

Ive heard he will play.