If Crichton leaves

[roosterchook]

I’m in two minds about Crichton. I don’t want to see him leave if he plays like he has recently but overall I don’t think we have been getting our money’s worth from him until just the last few matches. If he can keep this form up keep him, but I don’t want to carry an overpriced passenger unless he’s consistent.

[Easts75]

Been underwhelmed with Smith this year, seemed to excel with the faster rucks that came about from the 6again rulings but with rule changes reverting back and having minimal effect on the game now he seems to be far less effective.

Still does a lot of good off the ball in defence but on the ball this year he’s been disappointing. Only got 30minutes last night, 20minutes at lock to start the game then 10minutes at the end of the game at dummy half.

He will trim down with us to play 9 (didnt he say he put on about 8kg to play the rile The Storm want him to?? Huge amount for a small fella)
I have faith he will be sensational for us

[King Salvo]

Not sure that Smith is a long term dummy half as I see him more of bench impact player and loose running forward - Why they need to sign Tyler Moriarty before someone else does especially if Verrills possibly leaves.

Moriarty is a dummy half more than suited to the current game and is progressing nicely through the junior ranks similar to Sandon Smith's pathway- i.e Andrew Johns Cup/Harold Matthews Cup/Laurie Daley Cup/ SG Ball this year and now in the 17 in Jersey Flegg.- Selected in the NSW under 19's for next weeks game vs QLD under 19's and also in the Future/emerging NSW Blues squad last year

[Kelby]

Not sure that Smith is a long term dummy half as I see him more of bench impact player and loose running forward - Why they need to sign Tyler Moriarty before someone else does especially if Verrills possibly leaves - Moriarty is a dummy half more than suited to the current game

Agree. Why cant Rads play 2nd row?
That souffs flog murray does alright there.

[Easts75]

Not sure that Smith is a long term dummy half as I see him more of bench impact player and loose running forward - Why they need to sign Tyler Moriarty before someone else does especially if Verrills possibly leaves.

Moriarty is a dummy half more than suited to the current game and is progressing nicely through the junior ranks similar to Sandon Smith's pathway- i.e Andrew Johns Cup/Harold Matthews Cup/Laurie Daley Cup/ SG Ball this year and now in the 17 in Jersey Flegg.- Selected in the NSW under 19's for next weeks game vs QLD under 19's and also in the Future/emerging NSW Blues squad last year

So Moriarty is 19 ? How far from first grade IF he makes it ??
Smith is a gun ready to go. He will get to come here and play his preferred postion week in week out. He will kill it for us
By all means hope we secure Moriarty by the sounds of things, but he could be years away yet

[Bondicigar]

I get fans wanting to make changes to the side after a loss but moving Smith out of the 9 into the second row for the chooks while he's still in Melboure is next level

[Rooster1908]

I get fans wanting to make changes to the side after a loss but moving Smith out of the 9 into the second row for the chooks while he's still in Melboure is next level

Maybe Munster to 9

[Bondicigar]

Straight swap? The poor bloke seems very disinterested up on the GC.

I think he's disinterested on the footy field and it probably wouldn't matter which one.

[Roosterfarian]

Angus + Keary = Munster